{"id":157688,"url":"https://ivod.ly.gov.tw/Play/Clip/1M/157688","video_url":"https://ivod-lyvod.cdn.hinet.net/vod_1/_definst_/mp4:1MClips/884fcb4bd77b7063bfacd9e6ec65c28e53f20b0db47dadbcaa176a6e8d24ed95f22a5a2e4754ce135ea18f28b6918d91.mp4/playlist.m3u8","委員名稱":"吳思瑤","委員發言時間":"12:28:21 - 12:31:31","影片長度":"00:03:10","會議時間":"2024-11-29T09:00:00+08:00","會議名稱":"第11屆第2會期第11次會議（事由：一、討論事項：本院教育及文化委員會報告併案審查委員范雲等17人、委員林宜瑾等22人、委員張雅琳等19人分別擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」、委員李柏毅等18人擬具「學生輔導法第十一條條文修正草案」、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」、委員許智傑等25人擬具「學生輔導法第四條及第七條條文修正草案」、委員許智傑等26人擬具「學生輔導法第十一條條文修正草案」、委員柯志恩等18人擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」、委員陳培瑜等18人擬具「學生輔導法第十一條條文修正草案」、委員陳培瑜等18人擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」、委員洪孟楷等22人擬具「學生輔導法第十一條條文修正草案」、委員陳秀寳等20人擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」、委員郭昱晴等19人擬具「學生輔導法第十一條條文修正草案」、委員郭國文等19人擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」、委員郭國文等19人擬具「學生輔導法第十一條條文修正草案」、委員葛如鈞等16人擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」、台灣民眾黨黨團、委員吳沛憶等16人、委員王育敏等20人、委員萬美玲等19人分別擬具「學生輔導法第十一條條文修正草案」、委員羅智強等16人擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」、委員陳亭妃等19人擬具「學生輔導法第五條及第七條條文修正草案」、委員馬文君等24人擬具「學生輔導法第五條條文修正草案」、委員莊瑞雄等16人、委員陳菁徽等20人分別擬具「學生輔導法第十一條條文修正草案」、委員林月琴等19人、委員萬美玲等17人分別擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」、委員林俊憲等18人擬具「學生輔導法第十一條及第十一條之一條文修正草案」、委員羅廷瑋等19人及委員廖偉翔等16人分別擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」案；行政院函請審議「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」案；本院委員吳思瑤等17人擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」，請審議案；本院委員徐巧芯等17人擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」，請審議案；本院委員蔡易餘等23人擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」，請審議案；本院委員林思銘等19人擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」，請審議案；本院委員楊瓊瓔等25人擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」，請審議案等14案。 二、11月29日上午9時至10時為國是論壇時間。）","type":"Clip","date":"2024-11-29","start_time":"2024-11-29T12:28:21+08:00","end_time":"2024-11-29T12:31:31+08:00","duration":190,"meet":{"tmpMeeting":null,"title":"第11屆第2會期第11次會議","id":"院會-11-2-11","type":"院會","term":11,"sessionPeriod":2,"sessionTimes":11},"features":["ai-transcript","gazette"],"transcript":{"id":"157688","pyannote":{"name":"ronny","tool":"pyannote","data":{"url":"https://ivod.ly.gov.tw/Play/Clip/1M/157688","tool":"pyannote","id":"157688-pyannote"},"job_id":"UNB8BkL8jtlFWG9L","queued_at":"2024-11-29 13:15:12","status":"done","log":[{"time":"2024-11-29 13:16:14","msg":"downloading https://ivod.ly.gov.tw/Play/Clip/1M/157688","target":null},{"time":"2024-11-29 13:16:15","msg":"download ivod and merge to wav","target":"/home/conda/test/whisper-api-data/tmp/lyivod-clip-157688.wav"},{"time":"2024-11-29 13:16:24","msg":"running pyannote","target":null},{"time":"2024-11-29 13:16:32","msg":"status: done","target":null}],"result":{"result":[[0.03096875,8.82284375,"SPEAKER_00"],[9.430343750000002,171.00846875000002,"SPEAKER_00"],[171.26159375,181.30221875,"SPEAKER_00"],[181.85909375,188.35596875000002,"SPEAKER_00"]]}},"whisperx":{"name":"ronny","tool":"whisperx","data":{"url":"https://ivod.ly.gov.tw/Play/Clip/1M/157688","tool":"whisperx","id":"157688-whisperx","init_prompt":"會議名稱：第11屆第2會期第11次會議（事由：一、討論事項：本院教育及文化委員會報告併案審查委員范雲等17人、委員林宜瑾等22人、委員張雅琳等19人分別擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」、委員李柏毅等18人擬具「學生輔導法第十一條條文修正草案」、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」、"},"job_id":"PdVsisNI2zJYSjFS","queued_at":"2024-11-29 13:15:13","status":"done","log":[{"time":"2024-11-29 13:16:32","msg":"downloading https://ivod.ly.gov.tw/Play/Clip/1M/157688","target":null},{"time":"2024-11-29 13:16:32","msg":"already downloaded","target":"/home/conda/test/whisper-api-data/tmp/lyivod-clip-157688.wav"},{"time":"2024-11-29 13:16:32","msg":"running whisperx with  --language zh --model large-v3 --initial_prompt '會議名稱：第11屆第2會期第11次會議（事由：一、討論事項：本院教育及文化委員會報告併案審查委員范雲等17人、委員林宜瑾等22人、委員張雅琳等19人分別擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」、委員李柏毅等18人擬具「學生輔導法第十一條條文修正草案」、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案」、'","target":null},{"time":"2024-11-29 13:16:46","msg":"merging result","target":null},{"time":"2024-11-29 13:16:46","msg":"status: done","target":null}],"result":{"json":"{\"segments\": [{\"start\": 0.609, \"end\": 19.515, \"text\": \"委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳\", \"words\": [{\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 0.609, \"end\": 0.769, \"score\": 0.874}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 0.769, \"end\": 1.069, \"score\": 0.933}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 1.069, \"end\": 1.349, \"score\": 0.928}, {\"word\": \"等\", \"start\": 1.349, \"end\": 1.489, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"8\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 1.489, \"end\": 1.63, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"擬\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 1.63, \"end\": 1.69, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \":\"}, {\"word\": \"「\"}, {\"word\": \"學\", \"start\": 1.69, \"end\": 1.83, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 1.83, \"end\": 2.03, \"score\": 0.9}, {\"word\": \"輔\"}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 2.03, \"end\": 2.73, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 2.73, \"end\": 2.99, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 2.99, \"end\": 3.11, \"score\": 0.834}, {\"word\": \"條\"}, {\"word\": \"文\", \"start\": 3.11, \"end\": 3.29, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 3.29, \"end\": 3.35, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 3.35, \"end\": 3.41, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \"草\", \"start\": 3.41, \"end\": 3.61, \"score\": 0.9}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 3.61, \"end\": 3.65, \"score\": 0.5}, {\"word\": \"》\"}, {\"word\": \"、\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 3.65, \"end\": 4.17, \"score\": 0.961}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 4.17, \"end\": 4.31, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 4.31, \"end\": 4.43, \"score\": 0.833}, {\"word\": \"等\", \"start\": 4.43, \"end\": 4.611, \"score\": 0.888}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"8\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 4.611, \"end\": 4.711, \"score\": 0.8}, {\"word\": \"擬\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 4.711, \"end\": 4.771, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \":\"}, {\"word\": \"「\"}, {\"word\": \"學\", \"start\": 4.771, \"end\": 4.871, \"score\": 0.8}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 4.871, \"end\": 4.951, \"score\": 0.75}, {\"word\": \"輔\"}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 4.951, \"end\": 5.071, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 5.071, \"end\": 5.151, \"score\": 0.75}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 5.151, \"end\": 5.831, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"條\"}, {\"word\": \"文\", \"start\": 5.831, \"end\": 6.111, \"score\": 0.929}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 6.111, \"end\": 6.411, \"score\": 0.933}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 6.411, \"end\": 6.651, \"score\": 0.846}, {\"word\": \"草\", \"start\": 6.651, \"end\": 6.791, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 6.791, \"end\": 6.931, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"》\"}, {\"word\": \"、\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 6.931, \"end\": 7.211, \"score\": 0.929}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 7.211, \"end\": 7.251, \"score\": 0.5}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 7.251, \"end\": 7.431, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"等\", \"start\": 7.431, \"end\": 7.491, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"8\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 7.491, \"end\": 7.551, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \"擬\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 7.551, \"end\": 7.611, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \":\"}, {\"word\": \"「\"}, {\"word\": \"學\", \"start\": 7.611, \"end\": 7.792, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 7.792, \"end\": 7.912, \"score\": 0.833}, {\"word\": \"輔\"}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 7.912, \"end\": 8.032, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 8.032, \"end\": 8.052, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 8.052, \"end\": 8.112, \"score\": 0.666}, {\"word\": \"條\"}, {\"word\": \"文\", \"start\": 8.112, \"end\": 8.252, \"score\": 0.856}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 8.252, \"end\": 8.412, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 8.412, \"end\": 8.852, \"score\": 0.955}, {\"word\": \"草\", \"start\": 8.852, \"end\": 8.972, \"score\": 0.833}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 8.972, \"end\": 8.992, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"》\"}, {\"word\": \"、\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 8.992, \"end\": 9.192, \"score\": 0.9}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 9.192, \"end\": 9.212, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 9.212, \"end\": 9.472, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"等\", \"start\": 9.472, \"end\": 9.532, \"score\": 0.666}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"8\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 9.532, \"end\": 9.712, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"擬\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 9.712, \"end\": 9.812, \"score\": 0.8}, {\"word\": \":\"}, {\"word\": \"「\"}, {\"word\": \"學\", \"start\": 9.812, \"end\": 10.012, \"score\": 0.9}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 10.012, \"end\": 10.172, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"輔\"}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 10.172, \"end\": 10.292, \"score\": 0.833}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 10.292, \"end\": 10.312, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 10.312, \"end\": 10.412, \"score\": 0.8}, {\"word\": \"條\"}, {\"word\": \"文\", \"start\": 10.412, \"end\": 10.913, \"score\": 0.96}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 10.913, \"end\": 10.953, \"score\": 0.5}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 10.953, \"end\": 11.213, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"草\", \"start\": 11.213, \"end\": 11.533, \"score\": 0.937}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 11.533, \"end\": 11.753, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"》\"}, {\"word\": \"、\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 11.753, \"end\": 11.853, \"score\": 0.8}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 11.853, \"end\": 11.873, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 11.873, \"end\": 11.973, \"score\": 0.8}, {\"word\": \"等\", \"start\": 11.973, \"end\": 11.993, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"8\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 11.993, \"end\": 12.033, \"score\": 0.5}, {\"word\": \"擬\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 12.033, \"end\": 12.113, \"score\": 0.75}, {\"word\": \":\"}, {\"word\": \"「\"}, {\"word\": \"學\", \"start\": 12.113, \"end\": 12.273, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 12.273, \"end\": 12.293, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"輔\"}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 12.293, \"end\": 12.313, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 12.313, \"end\": 12.373, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 12.373, \"end\": 12.553, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"條\"}, {\"word\": \"文\", \"start\": 12.553, \"end\": 12.953, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 12.953, \"end\": 13.273, \"score\": 0.937}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 13.273, \"end\": 13.333, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \"草\", \"start\": 13.333, \"end\": 13.493, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 13.493, \"end\": 13.513, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"》\"}, {\"word\": \"、\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 13.513, \"end\": 13.653, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 13.653, \"end\": 14.034, \"score\": 0.947}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 14.034, \"end\": 14.394, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"等\", \"start\": 14.394, \"end\": 14.534, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"8\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 14.534, \"end\": 14.654, \"score\": 0.833}, {\"word\": \"擬\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 14.654, \"end\": 14.954, \"score\": 0.933}, {\"word\": \":\"}, {\"word\": \"「\"}, {\"word\": \"學\", \"start\": 14.954, \"end\": 15.234, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 15.234, \"end\": 15.414, \"score\": 0.87}, {\"word\": \"輔\"}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 15.414, \"end\": 15.494, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 15.494, \"end\": 15.574, \"score\": 0.75}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 15.574, \"end\": 15.834, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"條\"}, {\"word\": \"文\", \"start\": 15.834, \"end\": 16.134, \"score\": 0.933}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 16.134, \"end\": 16.534, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 16.534, \"end\": 16.554, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"草\", \"start\": 16.554, \"end\": 16.774, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 16.774, \"end\": 16.955, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"》\"}, {\"word\": \"、\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 16.955, \"end\": 17.035, \"score\": 0.75}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 17.035, \"end\": 17.135, \"score\": 0.8}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 17.135, \"end\": 17.155, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"等\", \"start\": 17.155, \"end\": 17.175, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"8\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 17.175, \"end\": 17.195, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"擬\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 17.195, \"end\": 17.275, \"score\": 0.749}, {\"word\": \":\"}, {\"word\": \"「\"}, {\"word\": \"學\", \"start\": 17.275, \"end\": 17.515, \"score\": 0.916}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 17.515, \"end\": 17.735, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"輔\"}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 17.735, \"end\": 17.915, \"score\": 0.888}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 17.915, \"end\": 17.935, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 17.935, \"end\": 17.955, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"條\"}, {\"word\": \"文\", \"start\": 17.955, \"end\": 18.075, \"score\": 0.833}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 18.075, \"end\": 18.355, \"score\": 0.929}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 18.355, \"end\": 18.915, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"草\", \"start\": 18.915, \"end\": 19.095, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 19.095, \"end\": 19.315, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"》\"}, {\"word\": \"、\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 19.315, \"end\": 19.455, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 19.455, \"end\": 19.495, \"score\": 0.5}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 19.495, \"end\": 19.515, \"score\": 0.0}]}, {\"start\": 21.536, \"end\": 43.343, \"text\": \"都告訴了我們權力之相互制衡有其界限除了不能抵觸憲法之規定更不能侵犯各個憲法機關的權力核心領域或者對於其他憲法機關權力之行使來造成實質妨害導致責任政治崩壞\", \"words\": [{\"word\": \"都\", \"start\": 21.536, \"end\": 21.796, \"score\": 0.995}, {\"word\": \"告\", \"start\": 21.796, \"end\": 22.256, \"score\": 0.956}, {\"word\": \"訴\"}, {\"word\": \"了\", \"start\": 22.256, \"end\": 22.396, \"score\": 0.986}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 22.396, \"end\": 23.537, \"score\": 0.961}, {\"word\": \"們\"}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"力\", \"start\": 23.537, \"end\": 23.737, \"score\": 0.905}, {\"word\": \"之\", \"start\": 23.737, \"end\": 23.997, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"相\", \"start\": 23.997, \"end\": 24.297, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"互\", \"start\": 24.297, \"end\": 24.577, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 24.577, \"end\": 24.817, \"score\": 0.931}, {\"word\": \"衡\", \"start\": 24.817, \"end\": 25.257, \"score\": 0.968}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 25.257, \"end\": 25.657, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"其\", \"start\": 25.657, \"end\": 26.017, \"score\": 0.987}, {\"word\": \"界\", \"start\": 26.017, \"end\": 26.317, \"score\": 0.985}, {\"word\": \"限\", \"start\": 26.317, \"end\": 27.018, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"除\", \"start\": 27.018, \"end\": 27.258, \"score\": 0.942}, {\"word\": \"了\", \"start\": 27.258, \"end\": 27.438, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 27.438, \"end\": 27.558, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"能\", \"start\": 27.558, \"end\": 27.778, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"抵\", \"start\": 27.778, \"end\": 28.398, \"score\": 0.93}, {\"word\": \"觸\"}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 28.398, \"end\": 28.598, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"之\", \"start\": 28.598, \"end\": 29.098, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"規\"}, {\"word\": \"定\", \"start\": 29.098, \"end\": 29.679, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"更\", \"start\": 29.679, \"end\": 29.959, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 29.959, \"end\": 30.099, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"能\", \"start\": 30.099, \"end\": 30.639, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"侵\", \"start\": 30.639, \"end\": 31.039, \"score\": 0.986}, {\"word\": \"犯\", \"start\": 31.039, \"end\": 31.379, \"score\": 0.989}, {\"word\": \"各\", \"start\": 31.379, \"end\": 31.919, \"score\": 0.916}, {\"word\": \"個\"}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 31.919, \"end\": 32.739, \"score\": 0.951}, {\"word\": \"機\"}, {\"word\": \"關\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 32.739, \"end\": 33.32, \"score\": 0.965}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"力\", \"start\": 33.32, \"end\": 33.48, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"核\", \"start\": 33.48, \"end\": 33.68, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"心\", \"start\": 33.68, \"end\": 34.12, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"領\"}, {\"word\": \"域\", \"start\": 34.12, \"end\": 34.66, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"或\", \"start\": 34.66, \"end\": 35.0, \"score\": 0.986}, {\"word\": \"者\", \"start\": 35.0, \"end\": 35.66, \"score\": 0.967}, {\"word\": \"對\"}, {\"word\": \"於\", \"start\": 35.66, \"end\": 35.92, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"其\", \"start\": 35.92, \"end\": 36.1, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"他\", \"start\": 36.1, \"end\": 36.481, \"score\": 0.945}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 36.481, \"end\": 37.381, \"score\": 0.933}, {\"word\": \"機\"}, {\"word\": \"關\"}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"力\", \"start\": 37.381, \"end\": 37.561, \"score\": 0.955}, {\"word\": \"之\", \"start\": 37.561, \"end\": 37.941, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"行\", \"start\": 37.941, \"end\": 38.281, \"score\": 0.968}, {\"word\": \"使\", \"start\": 38.281, \"end\": 39.001, \"score\": 0.962}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"造\", \"start\": 39.001, \"end\": 39.241, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"成\", \"start\": 39.241, \"end\": 40.702, \"score\": 0.955}, {\"word\": \"實\"}, {\"word\": \"質\"}, {\"word\": \"妨\"}, {\"word\": \"害\", \"start\": 40.702, \"end\": 41.682, \"score\": 0.978}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"致\", \"start\": 41.682, \"end\": 42.302, \"score\": 0.967}, {\"word\": \"責\"}, {\"word\": \"任\", \"start\": 42.302, \"end\": 42.662, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 42.662, \"end\": 42.983, \"score\": 0.969}, {\"word\": \"治\", \"start\": 42.983, \"end\": 43.323, \"score\": 0.943}, {\"word\": \"崩\", \"start\": 43.323, \"end\": 43.343, \"score\": 0.838}, {\"word\": \"壞\"}]}, {\"start\": 45.104, \"end\": 59.001, \"text\": \"這都是告訴我們立委要恪遵憲法切莫用修法的方式來介入行政權的人事任命權這一次原住民族組織法的修法重點兩項\", \"words\": [{\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"都\", \"start\": 45.104, \"end\": 45.404, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 45.404, \"end\": 45.665, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"告\", \"start\": 45.665, \"end\": 46.025, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"訴\"}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 46.025, \"end\": 46.826, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"們\"}, {\"word\": \"立\", \"start\": 46.826, \"end\": 47.106, \"score\": 0.934}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 47.106, \"end\": 47.487, \"score\": 0.951}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 47.487, \"end\": 48.128, \"score\": 0.963}, {\"word\": \"恪\"}, {\"word\": \"遵\", \"start\": 48.128, \"end\": 48.809, \"score\": 0.943}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 48.809, \"end\": 49.469, \"score\": 0.968}, {\"word\": \"切\", \"start\": 49.469, \"end\": 49.71, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"莫\", \"start\": 49.71, \"end\": 49.89, \"score\": 0.89}, {\"word\": \"用\", \"start\": 49.89, \"end\": 50.15, \"score\": 0.973}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 50.15, \"end\": 50.491, \"score\": 0.941}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 50.491, \"end\": 50.691, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 50.691, \"end\": 50.871, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"方\", \"start\": 50.871, \"end\": 51.131, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"式\", \"start\": 51.131, \"end\": 51.952, \"score\": 0.975}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"介\", \"start\": 51.952, \"end\": 52.233, \"score\": 0.961}, {\"word\": \"入\", \"start\": 52.233, \"end\": 52.673, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"行\", \"start\": 52.673, \"end\": 52.994, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 52.994, \"end\": 53.554, \"score\": 0.926}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 53.554, \"end\": 53.775, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 53.775, \"end\": 54.115, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"事\", \"start\": 54.115, \"end\": 54.335, \"score\": 0.914}, {\"word\": \"任\", \"start\": 54.335, \"end\": 54.496, \"score\": 0.988}, {\"word\": \"命\", \"start\": 54.496, \"end\": 55.757, \"score\": 0.947}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"一\", \"start\": 55.757, \"end\": 55.937, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"次\", \"start\": 55.937, \"end\": 56.238, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 56.238, \"end\": 56.438, \"score\": 0.981}, {\"word\": \"住\", \"start\": 56.438, \"end\": 56.558, \"score\": 0.84}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 56.558, \"end\": 56.778, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"族\", \"start\": 56.778, \"end\": 57.82, \"score\": 0.961}, {\"word\": \"組\"}, {\"word\": \"織\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 57.82, \"end\": 58.32, \"score\": 0.983}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 58.32, \"end\": 58.561, \"score\": 0.978}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 58.561, \"end\": 58.761, \"score\": 0.935}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 58.761, \"end\": 58.981, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"重\", \"start\": 58.981, \"end\": 59.001, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"點\"}, {\"word\": \"兩\"}, {\"word\": \"項\"}]}, {\"start\": 60.643, \"end\": 89.456, \"text\": \"不管是修法強制要求原住民族的主委要山地、平地來輪流擔任或是現有16位的族群委員由有己職改為無己職這些都是用修法的方式剝奪了憲法賦予行政權的人事任命權限甚至也大大的強害了現有的政務人員信賴保護的原則\", \"words\": [{\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 60.643, \"end\": 60.823, \"score\": 0.904}, {\"word\": \"管\", \"start\": 60.823, \"end\": 61.163, \"score\": 0.988}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 61.163, \"end\": 61.864, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 61.864, \"end\": 62.204, \"score\": 0.945}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 62.204, \"end\": 62.984, \"score\": 0.96}, {\"word\": \"強\"}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 62.984, \"end\": 63.204, \"score\": 0.913}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 63.204, \"end\": 63.464, \"score\": 0.916}, {\"word\": \"求\", \"start\": 63.464, \"end\": 63.664, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 63.664, \"end\": 63.844, \"score\": 0.945}, {\"word\": \"住\", \"start\": 63.844, \"end\": 63.985, \"score\": 0.72}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 63.985, \"end\": 64.145, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"族\", \"start\": 64.145, \"end\": 64.285, \"score\": 0.876}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 64.285, \"end\": 64.465, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"主\", \"start\": 64.465, \"end\": 64.805, \"score\": 0.926}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 64.805, \"end\": 65.365, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 65.365, \"end\": 65.825, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"山\", \"start\": 65.825, \"end\": 66.145, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"地\", \"start\": 66.145, \"end\": 66.426, \"score\": 0.96}, {\"word\": \"、\"}, {\"word\": \"平\", \"start\": 66.426, \"end\": 66.806, \"score\": 0.906}, {\"word\": \"地\", \"start\": 66.806, \"end\": 67.706, \"score\": 0.929}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"輪\"}, {\"word\": \"流\", \"start\": 67.706, \"end\": 68.266, \"score\": 0.935}, {\"word\": \"擔\"}, {\"word\": \"任\", \"start\": 68.266, \"end\": 68.907, \"score\": 0.986}, {\"word\": \"或\", \"start\": 68.907, \"end\": 69.227, \"score\": 0.943}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 69.227, \"end\": 70.067, \"score\": 0.947}, {\"word\": \"現\"}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 70.067, \"end\": 70.787, \"score\": 0.917}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"6\"}, {\"word\": \"位\", \"start\": 70.787, \"end\": 70.948, \"score\": 0.863}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 70.948, \"end\": 71.088, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"族\", \"start\": 71.088, \"end\": 71.288, \"score\": 0.99}, {\"word\": \"群\", \"start\": 71.288, \"end\": 71.548, \"score\": 0.985}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 71.548, \"end\": 72.548, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"由\", \"start\": 72.548, \"end\": 72.868, \"score\": 0.96}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 72.868, \"end\": 73.209, \"score\": 0.967}, {\"word\": \"己\", \"start\": 73.209, \"end\": 73.749, \"score\": 0.92}, {\"word\": \"職\"}, {\"word\": \"改\", \"start\": 73.749, \"end\": 74.249, \"score\": 0.886}, {\"word\": \"為\"}, {\"word\": \"無\", \"start\": 74.249, \"end\": 74.529, \"score\": 0.921}, {\"word\": \"己\", \"start\": 74.529, \"end\": 75.67, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"職\"}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"些\", \"start\": 75.67, \"end\": 75.95, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"都\", \"start\": 75.95, \"end\": 76.15, \"score\": 0.98}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 76.15, \"end\": 76.27, \"score\": 0.995}, {\"word\": \"用\", \"start\": 76.27, \"end\": 76.61, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 76.61, \"end\": 76.97, \"score\": 0.965}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 76.97, \"end\": 77.15, \"score\": 0.969}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 77.15, \"end\": 77.33, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"方\", \"start\": 77.33, \"end\": 77.61, \"score\": 0.975}, {\"word\": \"式\", \"start\": 77.61, \"end\": 78.771, \"score\": 0.951}, {\"word\": \"剝\"}, {\"word\": \"奪\"}, {\"word\": \"了\", \"start\": 78.771, \"end\": 79.471, \"score\": 0.97}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 79.471, \"end\": 79.951, \"score\": 0.955}, {\"word\": \"賦\"}, {\"word\": \"予\", \"start\": 79.951, \"end\": 80.232, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"行\", \"start\": 80.232, \"end\": 80.532, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 80.532, \"end\": 81.312, \"score\": 0.961}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 81.312, \"end\": 81.512, \"score\": 0.99}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 81.512, \"end\": 81.712, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"事\", \"start\": 81.712, \"end\": 81.852, \"score\": 0.832}, {\"word\": \"任\", \"start\": 81.852, \"end\": 82.012, \"score\": 0.878}, {\"word\": \"命\", \"start\": 82.012, \"end\": 82.493, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"限\", \"start\": 82.493, \"end\": 83.173, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"甚\", \"start\": 83.173, \"end\": 83.493, \"score\": 0.94}, {\"word\": \"至\", \"start\": 83.493, \"end\": 83.833, \"score\": 0.939}, {\"word\": \"也\", \"start\": 83.833, \"end\": 84.133, \"score\": 0.945}, {\"word\": \"大\", \"start\": 84.133, \"end\": 84.393, \"score\": 0.947}, {\"word\": \"大\", \"start\": 84.393, \"end\": 84.614, \"score\": 0.884}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 84.614, \"end\": 85.154, \"score\": 0.906}, {\"word\": \"強\"}, {\"word\": \"害\", \"start\": 85.154, \"end\": 85.434, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"了\", \"start\": 85.434, \"end\": 86.254, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"現\"}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 86.254, \"end\": 86.514, \"score\": 0.977}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 86.514, \"end\": 86.754, \"score\": 0.967}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 86.754, \"end\": 87.315, \"score\": 0.945}, {\"word\": \"務\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 87.315, \"end\": 88.015, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"信\", \"start\": 88.015, \"end\": 88.675, \"score\": 0.932}, {\"word\": \"賴\"}, {\"word\": \"保\", \"start\": 88.675, \"end\": 89.196, \"score\": 0.915}, {\"word\": \"護\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 89.196, \"end\": 89.436, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 89.436, \"end\": 89.456, \"score\": 0.757}, {\"word\": \"則\"}]}, {\"start\": 90.496, \"end\": 114.499, \"text\": \"所以事法性大有問題,合理性當然也應當來審酌我想這樣將山地平地原住民這種殖民時期遺留下來的這種要打破的刻板框架都應當落實在現在立法院的修法思維當中只是非常可惜在野黨委員的提案\", \"words\": [{\"word\": \"所\", \"start\": 90.496, \"end\": 90.656, \"score\": 0.931}, {\"word\": \"以\", \"start\": 90.656, \"end\": 90.816, \"score\": 0.885}, {\"word\": \"事\", \"start\": 90.816, \"end\": 91.057, \"score\": 0.833}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 91.057, \"end\": 91.277, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"性\", \"start\": 91.277, \"end\": 91.777, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"大\", \"start\": 91.777, \"end\": 91.998, \"score\": 0.956}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 91.998, \"end\": 93.139, \"score\": 0.899}, {\"word\": \"問\"}, {\"word\": \"題\"}, {\"word\": \",\"}, {\"word\": \"合\", \"start\": 93.139, \"end\": 93.399, \"score\": 0.917}, {\"word\": \"理\", \"start\": 93.399, \"end\": 93.639, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"性\", \"start\": 93.639, \"end\": 94.46, \"score\": 0.922}, {\"word\": \"當\"}, {\"word\": \"然\", \"start\": 94.46, \"end\": 94.961, \"score\": 0.942}, {\"word\": \"也\", \"start\": 94.961, \"end\": 97.123, \"score\": 0.931}, {\"word\": \"應\"}, {\"word\": \"當\"}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"審\"}, {\"word\": \"酌\"}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 97.123, \"end\": 97.283, \"score\": 0.876}, {\"word\": \"想\", \"start\": 97.283, \"end\": 98.364, \"score\": 0.888}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"樣\"}, {\"word\": \"將\"}, {\"word\": \"山\", \"start\": 98.364, \"end\": 98.624, \"score\": 0.954}, {\"word\": \"地\", \"start\": 98.624, \"end\": 98.804, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"平\", \"start\": 98.804, \"end\": 98.964, \"score\": 0.929}, {\"word\": \"地\", \"start\": 98.964, \"end\": 99.125, \"score\": 0.911}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 99.125, \"end\": 99.365, \"score\": 0.885}, {\"word\": \"住\", \"start\": 99.365, \"end\": 99.525, \"score\": 0.872}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 99.525, \"end\": 100.186, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"種\"}, {\"word\": \"殖\", \"start\": 100.186, \"end\": 100.426, \"score\": 0.975}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 100.426, \"end\": 100.906, \"score\": 0.939}, {\"word\": \"時\"}, {\"word\": \"期\", \"start\": 100.906, \"end\": 101.447, \"score\": 0.852}, {\"word\": \"遺\"}, {\"word\": \"留\", \"start\": 101.447, \"end\": 101.627, \"score\": 0.858}, {\"word\": \"下\", \"start\": 101.627, \"end\": 102.188, \"score\": 0.921}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 102.188, \"end\": 103.088, \"score\": 0.925}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"種\"}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 103.088, \"end\": 103.369, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"打\", \"start\": 103.369, \"end\": 103.649, \"score\": 0.899}, {\"word\": \"破\", \"start\": 103.649, \"end\": 103.889, \"score\": 0.911}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 103.889, \"end\": 104.069, \"score\": 0.906}, {\"word\": \"刻\", \"start\": 104.069, \"end\": 104.35, \"score\": 0.829}, {\"word\": \"板\", \"start\": 104.35, \"end\": 104.63, \"score\": 0.941}, {\"word\": \"框\", \"start\": 104.63, \"end\": 105.03, \"score\": 0.955}, {\"word\": \"架\", \"start\": 105.03, \"end\": 105.751, \"score\": 0.91}, {\"word\": \"都\", \"start\": 105.751, \"end\": 106.712, \"score\": 0.863}, {\"word\": \"應\"}, {\"word\": \"當\"}, {\"word\": \"落\", \"start\": 106.712, \"end\": 107.232, \"score\": 0.89}, {\"word\": \"實\"}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 107.232, \"end\": 107.853, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"現\"}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 107.853, \"end\": 108.113, \"score\": 0.921}, {\"word\": \"立\", \"start\": 108.113, \"end\": 108.353, \"score\": 0.92}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 108.353, \"end\": 108.594, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"院\", \"start\": 108.594, \"end\": 108.854, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 108.854, \"end\": 109.034, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 109.034, \"end\": 109.334, \"score\": 0.917}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 109.334, \"end\": 109.615, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"思\", \"start\": 109.615, \"end\": 110.255, \"score\": 0.899}, {\"word\": \"維\"}, {\"word\": \"當\"}, {\"word\": \"中\", \"start\": 110.255, \"end\": 110.896, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"只\", \"start\": 110.896, \"end\": 111.096, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 111.096, \"end\": 111.457, \"score\": 0.986}, {\"word\": \"非\", \"start\": 111.457, \"end\": 111.677, \"score\": 0.948}, {\"word\": \"常\", \"start\": 111.677, \"end\": 111.997, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"可\", \"start\": 111.997, \"end\": 112.277, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"惜\", \"start\": 112.277, \"end\": 113.058, \"score\": 0.986}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 113.058, \"end\": 113.198, \"score\": 0.837}, {\"word\": \"野\", \"start\": 113.198, \"end\": 113.519, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"黨\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 113.519, \"end\": 113.919, \"score\": 0.931}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 113.919, \"end\": 114.159, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"提\", \"start\": 114.159, \"end\": 114.479, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 114.479, \"end\": 114.499, \"score\": 0.984}]}, {\"start\": 115.18, \"end\": 115.66, \"text\": \"委員黃秀芳等18人擬具\", \"words\": [{\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 115.18, \"end\": 115.2, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 115.2, \"end\": 115.24, \"score\": 0.499}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 115.24, \"end\": 115.46, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"等\", \"start\": 115.46, \"end\": 115.48, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"8\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 115.48, \"end\": 115.64, \"score\": 0.83}, {\"word\": \"擬\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 115.64, \"end\": 115.66, \"score\": 0.05}]}, {\"start\": 136.937, \"end\": 162.316, \"text\": \"不要分族群這是現在進步的趨勢至於族群委員有幾職的制度數十年來不論誰執政都是如此不要因為現在執政的是民進黨由民進黨任命的主委臨聘而來的族群委員就冠上了綠有有或是酬庸\", \"words\": [{\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 136.937, \"end\": 137.117, \"score\": 0.877}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 137.117, \"end\": 137.437, \"score\": 0.942}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 137.437, \"end\": 137.798, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"族\", \"start\": 137.798, \"end\": 138.158, \"score\": 0.943}, {\"word\": \"群\", \"start\": 138.158, \"end\": 138.899, \"score\": 0.941}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 138.899, \"end\": 139.379, \"score\": 0.898}, {\"word\": \"現\"}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 139.379, \"end\": 139.979, \"score\": 0.963}, {\"word\": \"進\"}, {\"word\": \"步\", \"start\": 139.979, \"end\": 140.139, \"score\": 0.743}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 140.139, \"end\": 141.32, \"score\": 0.921}, {\"word\": \"趨\"}, {\"word\": \"勢\"}, {\"word\": \"至\", \"start\": 141.32, \"end\": 141.5, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"於\", \"start\": 141.5, \"end\": 141.761, \"score\": 0.922}, {\"word\": \"族\", \"start\": 141.761, \"end\": 142.021, \"score\": 0.855}, {\"word\": \"群\", \"start\": 142.021, \"end\": 142.261, \"score\": 0.986}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 142.261, \"end\": 143.082, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 143.082, \"end\": 143.762, \"score\": 0.927}, {\"word\": \"幾\"}, {\"word\": \"職\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 143.762, \"end\": 143.962, \"score\": 0.947}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 143.962, \"end\": 144.242, \"score\": 0.878}, {\"word\": \"度\", \"start\": 144.242, \"end\": 145.223, \"score\": 0.922}, {\"word\": \"數\"}, {\"word\": \"十\", \"start\": 145.223, \"end\": 145.503, \"score\": 0.927}, {\"word\": \"年\", \"start\": 145.503, \"end\": 146.384, \"score\": 0.908}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 146.384, \"end\": 147.585, \"score\": 0.927}, {\"word\": \"論\"}, {\"word\": \"誰\"}, {\"word\": \"執\"}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 147.585, \"end\": 148.145, \"score\": 0.924}, {\"word\": \"都\", \"start\": 148.145, \"end\": 148.586, \"score\": 0.939}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 148.586, \"end\": 148.866, \"score\": 0.915}, {\"word\": \"如\", \"start\": 148.866, \"end\": 149.266, \"score\": 0.904}, {\"word\": \"此\", \"start\": 149.266, \"end\": 149.847, \"score\": 0.98}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 149.847, \"end\": 150.047, \"score\": 0.918}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 150.047, \"end\": 150.267, \"score\": 0.85}, {\"word\": \"因\", \"start\": 150.267, \"end\": 151.168, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"為\"}, {\"word\": \"現\"}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 151.168, \"end\": 151.708, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"執\"}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 151.708, \"end\": 151.968, \"score\": 0.926}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 151.968, \"end\": 152.188, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 152.188, \"end\": 152.488, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 152.488, \"end\": 153.769, \"score\": 0.886}, {\"word\": \"進\"}, {\"word\": \"黨\"}, {\"word\": \"由\", \"start\": 153.769, \"end\": 154.09, \"score\": 0.963}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 154.09, \"end\": 154.77, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"進\"}, {\"word\": \"黨\"}, {\"word\": \"任\", \"start\": 154.77, \"end\": 154.97, \"score\": 0.906}, {\"word\": \"命\", \"start\": 154.97, \"end\": 155.15, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 155.15, \"end\": 155.351, \"score\": 0.988}, {\"word\": \"主\", \"start\": 155.351, \"end\": 155.691, \"score\": 0.934}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 155.691, \"end\": 156.732, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"臨\"}, {\"word\": \"聘\", \"start\": 156.732, \"end\": 157.092, \"score\": 0.951}, {\"word\": \"而\", \"start\": 157.092, \"end\": 157.712, \"score\": 0.933}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 157.712, \"end\": 158.033, \"score\": 0.947}, {\"word\": \"族\", \"start\": 158.033, \"end\": 158.293, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"群\", \"start\": 158.293, \"end\": 158.513, \"score\": 0.91}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 158.513, \"end\": 159.293, \"score\": 0.948}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"就\", \"start\": 159.293, \"end\": 159.634, \"score\": 0.954}, {\"word\": \"冠\", \"start\": 159.634, \"end\": 159.934, \"score\": 0.978}, {\"word\": \"上\", \"start\": 159.934, \"end\": 160.474, \"score\": 0.907}, {\"word\": \"了\", \"start\": 160.474, \"end\": 160.715, \"score\": 0.872}, {\"word\": \"綠\"}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 160.715, \"end\": 160.955, \"score\": 0.896}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 160.955, \"end\": 161.435, \"score\": 0.935}, {\"word\": \"或\", \"start\": 161.435, \"end\": 161.675, \"score\": 0.899}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 161.675, \"end\": 161.975, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"酬\", \"start\": 161.975, \"end\": 162.296, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"庸\", \"start\": 162.296, \"end\": 162.316, \"score\": 0.001}]}, {\"start\": 162.876, \"end\": 187.93, \"text\": \"甚至倒比一揮把他們服務人民的薪資都砍光這對於信賴保護原則存在嗎?未來如果提起訴訟請問這種責任立法院負得起嗎?民進黨反對這次的修法謝謝謝謝吳思瑤委員發言接下來請鍾嘉斌委員發言李柏毅委員請準備\", \"words\": [{\"word\": \"甚\", \"start\": 162.876, \"end\": 163.096, \"score\": 0.931}, {\"word\": \"至\", \"start\": 163.096, \"end\": 163.336, \"score\": 0.963}, {\"word\": \"倒\", \"start\": 163.336, \"end\": 163.576, \"score\": 0.894}, {\"word\": \"比\", \"start\": 163.576, \"end\": 163.737, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"一\", \"start\": 163.737, \"end\": 164.517, \"score\": 0.974}, {\"word\": \"揮\"}, {\"word\": \"把\", \"start\": 164.517, \"end\": 164.717, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"他\", \"start\": 164.717, \"end\": 165.237, \"score\": 0.953}, {\"word\": \"們\"}, {\"word\": \"服\", \"start\": 165.237, \"end\": 165.678, \"score\": 0.953}, {\"word\": \"務\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 165.678, \"end\": 165.878, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 165.878, \"end\": 166.278, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 166.278, \"end\": 166.518, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"薪\", \"start\": 166.518, \"end\": 167.098, \"score\": 0.931}, {\"word\": \"資\"}, {\"word\": \"都\", \"start\": 167.098, \"end\": 167.779, \"score\": 0.966}, {\"word\": \"砍\"}, {\"word\": \"光\", \"start\": 167.779, \"end\": 168.979, \"score\": 0.96}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"對\"}, {\"word\": \"於\", \"start\": 168.979, \"end\": 169.26, \"score\": 0.929}, {\"word\": \"信\", \"start\": 169.26, \"end\": 169.7, \"score\": 0.924}, {\"word\": \"賴\"}, {\"word\": \"保\", \"start\": 169.7, \"end\": 170.14, \"score\": 0.922}, {\"word\": \"護\"}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 170.14, \"end\": 171.421, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"則\"}, {\"word\": \"存\", \"start\": 171.421, \"end\": 171.781, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 171.781, \"end\": 172.641, \"score\": 0.97}, {\"word\": \"嗎\"}, {\"word\": \"?\"}, {\"word\": \"未\", \"start\": 172.641, \"end\": 173.182, \"score\": 0.962}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"如\", \"start\": 173.182, \"end\": 173.482, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"果\", \"start\": 173.482, \"end\": 173.742, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"提\", \"start\": 173.742, \"end\": 174.042, \"score\": 0.975}, {\"word\": \"起\", \"start\": 174.042, \"end\": 176.323, \"score\": 0.939}, {\"word\": \"訴\"}, {\"word\": \"訟\"}, {\"word\": \"請\"}, {\"word\": \"問\"}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"種\"}, {\"word\": \"責\"}, {\"word\": \"任\", \"start\": 176.323, \"end\": 176.744, \"score\": 0.99}, {\"word\": \"立\", \"start\": 176.744, \"end\": 177.004, \"score\": 0.985}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 177.004, \"end\": 177.204, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"院\", \"start\": 177.204, \"end\": 177.564, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"負\", \"start\": 177.564, \"end\": 177.744, \"score\": 0.789}, {\"word\": \"得\", \"start\": 177.744, \"end\": 177.904, \"score\": 0.886}, {\"word\": \"起\", \"start\": 177.904, \"end\": 178.645, \"score\": 0.963}, {\"word\": \"嗎\"}, {\"word\": \"?\"}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 178.645, \"end\": 179.165, \"score\": 0.887}, {\"word\": \"進\"}, {\"word\": \"黨\"}, {\"word\": \"反\", \"start\": 179.165, \"end\": 179.965, \"score\": 0.949}, {\"word\": \"對\"}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"次\", \"start\": 179.965, \"end\": 180.145, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 180.145, \"end\": 180.326, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 180.326, \"end\": 180.586, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 180.586, \"end\": 182.687, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"謝\"}, {\"word\": \"謝\"}, {\"word\": \"謝\"}, {\"word\": \"謝\"}, {\"word\": \"吳\"}, {\"word\": \"思\", \"start\": 182.687, \"end\": 183.067, \"score\": 0.894}, {\"word\": \"瑤\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 183.067, \"end\": 183.627, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"發\"}, {\"word\": \"言\", \"start\": 183.627, \"end\": 183.968, \"score\": 0.983}, {\"word\": \"接\", \"start\": 183.968, \"end\": 184.148, \"score\": 0.947}, {\"word\": \"下\", \"start\": 184.148, \"end\": 185.628, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"請\"}, {\"word\": \"鍾\"}, {\"word\": \"嘉\", \"start\": 185.628, \"end\": 186.009, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"斌\", \"start\": 186.009, \"end\": 186.149, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 186.149, \"end\": 186.529, \"score\": 0.894}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"發\"}, {\"word\": \"言\", \"start\": 186.529, \"end\": 186.689, \"score\": 0.878}, {\"word\": \"李\", \"start\": 186.689, \"end\": 187.049, \"score\": 0.948}, {\"word\": \"柏\", \"start\": 187.049, \"end\": 187.309, \"score\": 0.925}, {\"word\": \"毅\", \"start\": 187.309, \"end\": 187.429, \"score\": 0.833}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 187.429, \"end\": 187.91, \"score\": 0.92}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"請\"}, {\"word\": \"準\", \"start\": 187.91, \"end\": 187.93, \"score\": 0.009}, {\"word\": \"備\"}]}], \"word_segments\": [{\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 0.609, \"end\": 0.769, \"score\": 0.874}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 0.769, \"end\": 1.069, \"score\": 0.933}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 1.069, \"end\": 1.349, \"score\": 0.928}, {\"word\": \"等\", \"start\": 1.349, \"end\": 1.489, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"8\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 1.489, \"end\": 1.63, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"擬\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 1.63, \"end\": 1.69, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \":\"}, {\"word\": \"「\"}, {\"word\": \"學\", \"start\": 1.69, \"end\": 1.83, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 1.83, \"end\": 2.03, \"score\": 0.9}, {\"word\": \"輔\"}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 2.03, \"end\": 2.73, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 2.73, \"end\": 2.99, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 2.99, \"end\": 3.11, \"score\": 0.834}, {\"word\": \"條\"}, {\"word\": \"文\", \"start\": 3.11, \"end\": 3.29, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 3.29, \"end\": 3.35, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 3.35, \"end\": 3.41, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \"草\", \"start\": 3.41, \"end\": 3.61, \"score\": 0.9}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 3.61, \"end\": 3.65, \"score\": 0.5}, {\"word\": \"》\"}, {\"word\": \"、\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 3.65, \"end\": 4.17, \"score\": 0.961}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 4.17, \"end\": 4.31, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 4.31, \"end\": 4.43, \"score\": 0.833}, {\"word\": \"等\", \"start\": 4.43, \"end\": 4.611, \"score\": 0.888}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"8\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 4.611, \"end\": 4.711, \"score\": 0.8}, {\"word\": \"擬\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 4.711, \"end\": 4.771, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \":\"}, {\"word\": \"「\"}, {\"word\": \"學\", \"start\": 4.771, \"end\": 4.871, \"score\": 0.8}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 4.871, \"end\": 4.951, \"score\": 0.75}, {\"word\": \"輔\"}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 4.951, \"end\": 5.071, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 5.071, \"end\": 5.151, \"score\": 0.75}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 5.151, \"end\": 5.831, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"條\"}, {\"word\": \"文\", \"start\": 5.831, \"end\": 6.111, \"score\": 0.929}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 6.111, \"end\": 6.411, \"score\": 0.933}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 6.411, \"end\": 6.651, \"score\": 0.846}, {\"word\": \"草\", \"start\": 6.651, \"end\": 6.791, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 6.791, \"end\": 6.931, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"》\"}, {\"word\": \"、\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 6.931, \"end\": 7.211, \"score\": 0.929}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 7.211, \"end\": 7.251, \"score\": 0.5}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 7.251, \"end\": 7.431, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"等\", \"start\": 7.431, \"end\": 7.491, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"8\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 7.491, \"end\": 7.551, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \"擬\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 7.551, \"end\": 7.611, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \":\"}, {\"word\": \"「\"}, {\"word\": \"學\", \"start\": 7.611, \"end\": 7.792, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 7.792, \"end\": 7.912, \"score\": 0.833}, {\"word\": \"輔\"}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 7.912, \"end\": 8.032, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 8.032, \"end\": 8.052, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 8.052, \"end\": 8.112, \"score\": 0.666}, {\"word\": \"條\"}, {\"word\": \"文\", \"start\": 8.112, \"end\": 8.252, \"score\": 0.856}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 8.252, \"end\": 8.412, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 8.412, \"end\": 8.852, \"score\": 0.955}, {\"word\": \"草\", \"start\": 8.852, \"end\": 8.972, \"score\": 0.833}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 8.972, \"end\": 8.992, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"》\"}, {\"word\": \"、\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 8.992, \"end\": 9.192, \"score\": 0.9}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 9.192, \"end\": 9.212, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 9.212, \"end\": 9.472, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"等\", \"start\": 9.472, \"end\": 9.532, \"score\": 0.666}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"8\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 9.532, \"end\": 9.712, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"擬\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 9.712, \"end\": 9.812, \"score\": 0.8}, {\"word\": \":\"}, {\"word\": \"「\"}, {\"word\": \"學\", \"start\": 9.812, \"end\": 10.012, \"score\": 0.9}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 10.012, \"end\": 10.172, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"輔\"}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 10.172, \"end\": 10.292, \"score\": 0.833}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 10.292, \"end\": 10.312, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 10.312, \"end\": 10.412, \"score\": 0.8}, {\"word\": \"條\"}, {\"word\": \"文\", \"start\": 10.412, \"end\": 10.913, \"score\": 0.96}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 10.913, \"end\": 10.953, \"score\": 0.5}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 10.953, \"end\": 11.213, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"草\", \"start\": 11.213, \"end\": 11.533, \"score\": 0.937}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 11.533, \"end\": 11.753, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"》\"}, {\"word\": \"、\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 11.753, \"end\": 11.853, \"score\": 0.8}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 11.853, \"end\": 11.873, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 11.873, \"end\": 11.973, \"score\": 0.8}, {\"word\": \"等\", \"start\": 11.973, \"end\": 11.993, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"8\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 11.993, \"end\": 12.033, \"score\": 0.5}, {\"word\": \"擬\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 12.033, \"end\": 12.113, \"score\": 0.75}, {\"word\": \":\"}, {\"word\": \"「\"}, {\"word\": \"學\", \"start\": 12.113, \"end\": 12.273, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 12.273, \"end\": 12.293, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"輔\"}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 12.293, \"end\": 12.313, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 12.313, \"end\": 12.373, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 12.373, \"end\": 12.553, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"條\"}, {\"word\": \"文\", \"start\": 12.553, \"end\": 12.953, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 12.953, \"end\": 13.273, \"score\": 0.937}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 13.273, \"end\": 13.333, \"score\": 0.667}, {\"word\": \"草\", \"start\": 13.333, \"end\": 13.493, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 13.493, \"end\": 13.513, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"》\"}, {\"word\": \"、\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 13.513, \"end\": 13.653, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 13.653, \"end\": 14.034, \"score\": 0.947}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 14.034, \"end\": 14.394, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"等\", \"start\": 14.394, \"end\": 14.534, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"8\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 14.534, \"end\": 14.654, \"score\": 0.833}, {\"word\": \"擬\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 14.654, \"end\": 14.954, \"score\": 0.933}, {\"word\": \":\"}, {\"word\": \"「\"}, {\"word\": \"學\", \"start\": 14.954, \"end\": 15.234, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 15.234, \"end\": 15.414, \"score\": 0.87}, {\"word\": \"輔\"}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 15.414, \"end\": 15.494, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 15.494, \"end\": 15.574, \"score\": 0.75}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 15.574, \"end\": 15.834, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"條\"}, {\"word\": \"文\", \"start\": 15.834, \"end\": 16.134, \"score\": 0.933}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 16.134, \"end\": 16.534, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 16.534, \"end\": 16.554, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"草\", \"start\": 16.554, \"end\": 16.774, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 16.774, \"end\": 16.955, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"》\"}, {\"word\": \"、\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 16.955, \"end\": 17.035, \"score\": 0.75}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 17.035, \"end\": 17.135, \"score\": 0.8}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 17.135, \"end\": 17.155, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"等\", \"start\": 17.155, \"end\": 17.175, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"8\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 17.175, \"end\": 17.195, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"擬\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 17.195, \"end\": 17.275, \"score\": 0.749}, {\"word\": \":\"}, {\"word\": \"「\"}, {\"word\": \"學\", \"start\": 17.275, \"end\": 17.515, \"score\": 0.916}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 17.515, \"end\": 17.735, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"輔\"}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 17.735, \"end\": 17.915, \"score\": 0.888}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 17.915, \"end\": 17.935, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 17.935, \"end\": 17.955, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"條\"}, {\"word\": \"文\", \"start\": 17.955, \"end\": 18.075, \"score\": 0.833}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 18.075, \"end\": 18.355, \"score\": 0.929}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 18.355, \"end\": 18.915, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"草\", \"start\": 18.915, \"end\": 19.095, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 19.095, \"end\": 19.315, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"》\"}, {\"word\": \"、\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 19.315, \"end\": 19.455, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 19.455, \"end\": 19.495, \"score\": 0.5}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 19.495, \"end\": 19.515, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"都\", \"start\": 21.536, \"end\": 21.796, \"score\": 0.995}, {\"word\": \"告\", \"start\": 21.796, \"end\": 22.256, \"score\": 0.956}, {\"word\": \"訴\"}, {\"word\": \"了\", \"start\": 22.256, \"end\": 22.396, \"score\": 0.986}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 22.396, \"end\": 23.537, \"score\": 0.961}, {\"word\": \"們\"}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"力\", \"start\": 23.537, \"end\": 23.737, \"score\": 0.905}, {\"word\": \"之\", \"start\": 23.737, \"end\": 23.997, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"相\", \"start\": 23.997, \"end\": 24.297, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"互\", \"start\": 24.297, \"end\": 24.577, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 24.577, \"end\": 24.817, \"score\": 0.931}, {\"word\": \"衡\", \"start\": 24.817, \"end\": 25.257, \"score\": 0.968}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 25.257, \"end\": 25.657, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"其\", \"start\": 25.657, \"end\": 26.017, \"score\": 0.987}, {\"word\": \"界\", \"start\": 26.017, \"end\": 26.317, \"score\": 0.985}, {\"word\": \"限\", \"start\": 26.317, \"end\": 27.018, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"除\", \"start\": 27.018, \"end\": 27.258, \"score\": 0.942}, {\"word\": \"了\", \"start\": 27.258, \"end\": 27.438, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 27.438, \"end\": 27.558, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"能\", \"start\": 27.558, \"end\": 27.778, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"抵\", \"start\": 27.778, \"end\": 28.398, \"score\": 0.93}, {\"word\": \"觸\"}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 28.398, \"end\": 28.598, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"之\", \"start\": 28.598, \"end\": 29.098, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"規\"}, {\"word\": \"定\", \"start\": 29.098, \"end\": 29.679, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"更\", \"start\": 29.679, \"end\": 29.959, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 29.959, \"end\": 30.099, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"能\", \"start\": 30.099, \"end\": 30.639, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"侵\", \"start\": 30.639, \"end\": 31.039, \"score\": 0.986}, {\"word\": \"犯\", \"start\": 31.039, \"end\": 31.379, \"score\": 0.989}, {\"word\": \"各\", \"start\": 31.379, \"end\": 31.919, \"score\": 0.916}, {\"word\": \"個\"}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 31.919, \"end\": 32.739, \"score\": 0.951}, {\"word\": \"機\"}, {\"word\": \"關\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 32.739, \"end\": 33.32, \"score\": 0.965}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"力\", \"start\": 33.32, \"end\": 33.48, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"核\", \"start\": 33.48, \"end\": 33.68, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"心\", \"start\": 33.68, \"end\": 34.12, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"領\"}, {\"word\": \"域\", \"start\": 34.12, \"end\": 34.66, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"或\", \"start\": 34.66, \"end\": 35.0, \"score\": 0.986}, {\"word\": \"者\", \"start\": 35.0, \"end\": 35.66, \"score\": 0.967}, {\"word\": \"對\"}, {\"word\": \"於\", \"start\": 35.66, \"end\": 35.92, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"其\", \"start\": 35.92, \"end\": 36.1, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"他\", \"start\": 36.1, \"end\": 36.481, \"score\": 0.945}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 36.481, \"end\": 37.381, \"score\": 0.933}, {\"word\": \"機\"}, {\"word\": \"關\"}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"力\", \"start\": 37.381, \"end\": 37.561, \"score\": 0.955}, {\"word\": \"之\", \"start\": 37.561, \"end\": 37.941, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"行\", \"start\": 37.941, \"end\": 38.281, \"score\": 0.968}, {\"word\": \"使\", \"start\": 38.281, \"end\": 39.001, \"score\": 0.962}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"造\", \"start\": 39.001, \"end\": 39.241, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"成\", \"start\": 39.241, \"end\": 40.702, \"score\": 0.955}, {\"word\": \"實\"}, {\"word\": \"質\"}, {\"word\": \"妨\"}, {\"word\": \"害\", \"start\": 40.702, \"end\": 41.682, \"score\": 0.978}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"致\", \"start\": 41.682, \"end\": 42.302, \"score\": 0.967}, {\"word\": \"責\"}, {\"word\": \"任\", \"start\": 42.302, \"end\": 42.662, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 42.662, \"end\": 42.983, \"score\": 0.969}, {\"word\": \"治\", \"start\": 42.983, \"end\": 43.323, \"score\": 0.943}, {\"word\": \"崩\", \"start\": 43.323, \"end\": 43.343, \"score\": 0.838}, {\"word\": \"壞\"}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"都\", \"start\": 45.104, \"end\": 45.404, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 45.404, \"end\": 45.665, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"告\", \"start\": 45.665, \"end\": 46.025, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"訴\"}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 46.025, \"end\": 46.826, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"們\"}, {\"word\": \"立\", \"start\": 46.826, \"end\": 47.106, \"score\": 0.934}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 47.106, \"end\": 47.487, \"score\": 0.951}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 47.487, \"end\": 48.128, \"score\": 0.963}, {\"word\": \"恪\"}, {\"word\": \"遵\", \"start\": 48.128, \"end\": 48.809, \"score\": 0.943}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 48.809, \"end\": 49.469, \"score\": 0.968}, {\"word\": \"切\", \"start\": 49.469, \"end\": 49.71, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"莫\", \"start\": 49.71, \"end\": 49.89, \"score\": 0.89}, {\"word\": \"用\", \"start\": 49.89, \"end\": 50.15, \"score\": 0.973}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 50.15, \"end\": 50.491, \"score\": 0.941}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 50.491, \"end\": 50.691, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 50.691, \"end\": 50.871, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"方\", \"start\": 50.871, \"end\": 51.131, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"式\", \"start\": 51.131, \"end\": 51.952, \"score\": 0.975}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"介\", \"start\": 51.952, \"end\": 52.233, \"score\": 0.961}, {\"word\": \"入\", \"start\": 52.233, \"end\": 52.673, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"行\", \"start\": 52.673, \"end\": 52.994, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 52.994, \"end\": 53.554, \"score\": 0.926}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 53.554, \"end\": 53.775, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 53.775, \"end\": 54.115, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"事\", \"start\": 54.115, \"end\": 54.335, \"score\": 0.914}, {\"word\": \"任\", \"start\": 54.335, \"end\": 54.496, \"score\": 0.988}, {\"word\": \"命\", \"start\": 54.496, \"end\": 55.757, \"score\": 0.947}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"一\", \"start\": 55.757, \"end\": 55.937, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"次\", \"start\": 55.937, \"end\": 56.238, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 56.238, \"end\": 56.438, \"score\": 0.981}, {\"word\": \"住\", \"start\": 56.438, \"end\": 56.558, \"score\": 0.84}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 56.558, \"end\": 56.778, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"族\", \"start\": 56.778, \"end\": 57.82, \"score\": 0.961}, {\"word\": \"組\"}, {\"word\": \"織\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 57.82, \"end\": 58.32, \"score\": 0.983}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 58.32, \"end\": 58.561, \"score\": 0.978}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 58.561, \"end\": 58.761, \"score\": 0.935}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 58.761, \"end\": 58.981, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"重\", \"start\": 58.981, \"end\": 59.001, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"點\"}, {\"word\": \"兩\"}, {\"word\": \"項\"}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 60.643, \"end\": 60.823, \"score\": 0.904}, {\"word\": \"管\", \"start\": 60.823, \"end\": 61.163, \"score\": 0.988}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 61.163, \"end\": 61.864, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 61.864, \"end\": 62.204, \"score\": 0.945}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 62.204, \"end\": 62.984, \"score\": 0.96}, {\"word\": \"強\"}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 62.984, \"end\": 63.204, \"score\": 0.913}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 63.204, \"end\": 63.464, \"score\": 0.916}, {\"word\": \"求\", \"start\": 63.464, \"end\": 63.664, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 63.664, \"end\": 63.844, \"score\": 0.945}, {\"word\": \"住\", \"start\": 63.844, \"end\": 63.985, \"score\": 0.72}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 63.985, \"end\": 64.145, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"族\", \"start\": 64.145, \"end\": 64.285, \"score\": 0.876}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 64.285, \"end\": 64.465, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"主\", \"start\": 64.465, \"end\": 64.805, \"score\": 0.926}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 64.805, \"end\": 65.365, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 65.365, \"end\": 65.825, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"山\", \"start\": 65.825, \"end\": 66.145, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"地\", \"start\": 66.145, \"end\": 66.426, \"score\": 0.96}, {\"word\": \"、\"}, {\"word\": \"平\", \"start\": 66.426, \"end\": 66.806, \"score\": 0.906}, {\"word\": \"地\", \"start\": 66.806, \"end\": 67.706, \"score\": 0.929}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"輪\"}, {\"word\": \"流\", \"start\": 67.706, \"end\": 68.266, \"score\": 0.935}, {\"word\": \"擔\"}, {\"word\": \"任\", \"start\": 68.266, \"end\": 68.907, \"score\": 0.986}, {\"word\": \"或\", \"start\": 68.907, \"end\": 69.227, \"score\": 0.943}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 69.227, \"end\": 70.067, \"score\": 0.947}, {\"word\": \"現\"}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 70.067, \"end\": 70.787, \"score\": 0.917}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"6\"}, {\"word\": \"位\", \"start\": 70.787, \"end\": 70.948, \"score\": 0.863}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 70.948, \"end\": 71.088, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"族\", \"start\": 71.088, \"end\": 71.288, \"score\": 0.99}, {\"word\": \"群\", \"start\": 71.288, \"end\": 71.548, \"score\": 0.985}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 71.548, \"end\": 72.548, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"由\", \"start\": 72.548, \"end\": 72.868, \"score\": 0.96}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 72.868, \"end\": 73.209, \"score\": 0.967}, {\"word\": \"己\", \"start\": 73.209, \"end\": 73.749, \"score\": 0.92}, {\"word\": \"職\"}, {\"word\": \"改\", \"start\": 73.749, \"end\": 74.249, \"score\": 0.886}, {\"word\": \"為\"}, {\"word\": \"無\", \"start\": 74.249, \"end\": 74.529, \"score\": 0.921}, {\"word\": \"己\", \"start\": 74.529, \"end\": 75.67, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"職\"}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"些\", \"start\": 75.67, \"end\": 75.95, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"都\", \"start\": 75.95, \"end\": 76.15, \"score\": 0.98}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 76.15, \"end\": 76.27, \"score\": 0.995}, {\"word\": \"用\", \"start\": 76.27, \"end\": 76.61, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 76.61, \"end\": 76.97, \"score\": 0.965}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 76.97, \"end\": 77.15, \"score\": 0.969}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 77.15, \"end\": 77.33, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"方\", \"start\": 77.33, \"end\": 77.61, \"score\": 0.975}, {\"word\": \"式\", \"start\": 77.61, \"end\": 78.771, \"score\": 0.951}, {\"word\": \"剝\"}, {\"word\": \"奪\"}, {\"word\": \"了\", \"start\": 78.771, \"end\": 79.471, \"score\": 0.97}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 79.471, \"end\": 79.951, \"score\": 0.955}, {\"word\": \"賦\"}, {\"word\": \"予\", \"start\": 79.951, \"end\": 80.232, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"行\", \"start\": 80.232, \"end\": 80.532, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 80.532, \"end\": 81.312, \"score\": 0.961}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 81.312, \"end\": 81.512, \"score\": 0.99}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 81.512, \"end\": 81.712, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"事\", \"start\": 81.712, \"end\": 81.852, \"score\": 0.832}, {\"word\": \"任\", \"start\": 81.852, \"end\": 82.012, \"score\": 0.878}, {\"word\": \"命\", \"start\": 82.012, \"end\": 82.493, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"限\", \"start\": 82.493, \"end\": 83.173, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"甚\", \"start\": 83.173, \"end\": 83.493, \"score\": 0.94}, {\"word\": \"至\", \"start\": 83.493, \"end\": 83.833, \"score\": 0.939}, {\"word\": \"也\", \"start\": 83.833, \"end\": 84.133, \"score\": 0.945}, {\"word\": \"大\", \"start\": 84.133, \"end\": 84.393, \"score\": 0.947}, {\"word\": \"大\", \"start\": 84.393, \"end\": 84.614, \"score\": 0.884}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 84.614, \"end\": 85.154, \"score\": 0.906}, {\"word\": \"強\"}, {\"word\": \"害\", \"start\": 85.154, \"end\": 85.434, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"了\", \"start\": 85.434, \"end\": 86.254, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"現\"}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 86.254, \"end\": 86.514, \"score\": 0.977}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 86.514, \"end\": 86.754, \"score\": 0.967}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 86.754, \"end\": 87.315, \"score\": 0.945}, {\"word\": \"務\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 87.315, \"end\": 88.015, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"信\", \"start\": 88.015, \"end\": 88.675, \"score\": 0.932}, {\"word\": \"賴\"}, {\"word\": \"保\", \"start\": 88.675, \"end\": 89.196, \"score\": 0.915}, {\"word\": \"護\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 89.196, \"end\": 89.436, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 89.436, \"end\": 89.456, \"score\": 0.757}, {\"word\": \"則\"}, {\"word\": \"所\", \"start\": 90.496, \"end\": 90.656, \"score\": 0.931}, {\"word\": \"以\", \"start\": 90.656, \"end\": 90.816, \"score\": 0.885}, {\"word\": \"事\", \"start\": 90.816, \"end\": 91.057, \"score\": 0.833}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 91.057, \"end\": 91.277, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"性\", \"start\": 91.277, \"end\": 91.777, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"大\", \"start\": 91.777, \"end\": 91.998, \"score\": 0.956}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 91.998, \"end\": 93.139, \"score\": 0.899}, {\"word\": \"問\"}, {\"word\": \"題\"}, {\"word\": \",\"}, {\"word\": \"合\", \"start\": 93.139, \"end\": 93.399, \"score\": 0.917}, {\"word\": \"理\", \"start\": 93.399, \"end\": 93.639, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"性\", \"start\": 93.639, \"end\": 94.46, \"score\": 0.922}, {\"word\": \"當\"}, {\"word\": \"然\", \"start\": 94.46, \"end\": 94.961, \"score\": 0.942}, {\"word\": \"也\", \"start\": 94.961, \"end\": 97.123, \"score\": 0.931}, {\"word\": \"應\"}, {\"word\": \"當\"}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"審\"}, {\"word\": \"酌\"}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 97.123, \"end\": 97.283, \"score\": 0.876}, {\"word\": \"想\", \"start\": 97.283, \"end\": 98.364, \"score\": 0.888}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"樣\"}, {\"word\": \"將\"}, {\"word\": \"山\", \"start\": 98.364, \"end\": 98.624, \"score\": 0.954}, {\"word\": \"地\", \"start\": 98.624, \"end\": 98.804, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"平\", \"start\": 98.804, \"end\": 98.964, \"score\": 0.929}, {\"word\": \"地\", \"start\": 98.964, \"end\": 99.125, \"score\": 0.911}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 99.125, \"end\": 99.365, \"score\": 0.885}, {\"word\": \"住\", \"start\": 99.365, \"end\": 99.525, \"score\": 0.872}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 99.525, \"end\": 100.186, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"種\"}, {\"word\": \"殖\", \"start\": 100.186, \"end\": 100.426, \"score\": 0.975}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 100.426, \"end\": 100.906, \"score\": 0.939}, {\"word\": \"時\"}, {\"word\": \"期\", \"start\": 100.906, \"end\": 101.447, \"score\": 0.852}, {\"word\": \"遺\"}, {\"word\": \"留\", \"start\": 101.447, \"end\": 101.627, \"score\": 0.858}, {\"word\": \"下\", \"start\": 101.627, \"end\": 102.188, \"score\": 0.921}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 102.188, \"end\": 103.088, \"score\": 0.925}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"種\"}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 103.088, \"end\": 103.369, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"打\", \"start\": 103.369, \"end\": 103.649, \"score\": 0.899}, {\"word\": \"破\", \"start\": 103.649, \"end\": 103.889, \"score\": 0.911}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 103.889, \"end\": 104.069, \"score\": 0.906}, {\"word\": \"刻\", \"start\": 104.069, \"end\": 104.35, \"score\": 0.829}, {\"word\": \"板\", \"start\": 104.35, \"end\": 104.63, \"score\": 0.941}, {\"word\": \"框\", \"start\": 104.63, \"end\": 105.03, \"score\": 0.955}, {\"word\": \"架\", \"start\": 105.03, \"end\": 105.751, \"score\": 0.91}, {\"word\": \"都\", \"start\": 105.751, \"end\": 106.712, \"score\": 0.863}, {\"word\": \"應\"}, {\"word\": \"當\"}, {\"word\": \"落\", \"start\": 106.712, \"end\": 107.232, \"score\": 0.89}, {\"word\": \"實\"}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 107.232, \"end\": 107.853, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"現\"}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 107.853, \"end\": 108.113, \"score\": 0.921}, {\"word\": \"立\", \"start\": 108.113, \"end\": 108.353, \"score\": 0.92}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 108.353, \"end\": 108.594, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"院\", \"start\": 108.594, \"end\": 108.854, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 108.854, \"end\": 109.034, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 109.034, \"end\": 109.334, \"score\": 0.917}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 109.334, \"end\": 109.615, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"思\", \"start\": 109.615, \"end\": 110.255, \"score\": 0.899}, {\"word\": \"維\"}, {\"word\": \"當\"}, {\"word\": \"中\", \"start\": 110.255, \"end\": 110.896, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"只\", \"start\": 110.896, \"end\": 111.096, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 111.096, \"end\": 111.457, \"score\": 0.986}, {\"word\": \"非\", \"start\": 111.457, \"end\": 111.677, \"score\": 0.948}, {\"word\": \"常\", \"start\": 111.677, \"end\": 111.997, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"可\", \"start\": 111.997, \"end\": 112.277, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"惜\", \"start\": 112.277, \"end\": 113.058, \"score\": 0.986}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 113.058, \"end\": 113.198, \"score\": 0.837}, {\"word\": \"野\", \"start\": 113.198, \"end\": 113.519, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"黨\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 113.519, \"end\": 113.919, \"score\": 0.931}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 113.919, \"end\": 114.159, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"提\", \"start\": 114.159, \"end\": 114.479, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 114.479, \"end\": 114.499, \"score\": 0.984}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 115.18, \"end\": 115.2, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"黃\"}, {\"word\": \"秀\", \"start\": 115.2, \"end\": 115.24, \"score\": 0.499}, {\"word\": \"芳\", \"start\": 115.24, \"end\": 115.46, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"等\", \"start\": 115.46, \"end\": 115.48, \"score\": 0.0}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"8\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 115.48, \"end\": 115.64, \"score\": 0.83}, {\"word\": \"擬\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 115.64, \"end\": 115.66, \"score\": 0.05}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 136.937, \"end\": 137.117, \"score\": 0.877}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 137.117, \"end\": 137.437, \"score\": 0.942}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 137.437, \"end\": 137.798, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"族\", \"start\": 137.798, \"end\": 138.158, \"score\": 0.943}, {\"word\": \"群\", \"start\": 138.158, \"end\": 138.899, \"score\": 0.941}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 138.899, \"end\": 139.379, \"score\": 0.898}, {\"word\": \"現\"}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 139.379, \"end\": 139.979, \"score\": 0.963}, {\"word\": \"進\"}, {\"word\": \"步\", \"start\": 139.979, \"end\": 140.139, \"score\": 0.743}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 140.139, \"end\": 141.32, \"score\": 0.921}, {\"word\": \"趨\"}, {\"word\": \"勢\"}, {\"word\": \"至\", \"start\": 141.32, \"end\": 141.5, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"於\", \"start\": 141.5, \"end\": 141.761, \"score\": 0.922}, {\"word\": \"族\", \"start\": 141.761, \"end\": 142.021, \"score\": 0.855}, {\"word\": \"群\", \"start\": 142.021, \"end\": 142.261, \"score\": 0.986}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 142.261, \"end\": 143.082, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 143.082, \"end\": 143.762, \"score\": 0.927}, {\"word\": \"幾\"}, {\"word\": \"職\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 143.762, \"end\": 143.962, \"score\": 0.947}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 143.962, \"end\": 144.242, \"score\": 0.878}, {\"word\": \"度\", \"start\": 144.242, \"end\": 145.223, \"score\": 0.922}, {\"word\": \"數\"}, {\"word\": \"十\", \"start\": 145.223, \"end\": 145.503, \"score\": 0.927}, {\"word\": \"年\", \"start\": 145.503, \"end\": 146.384, \"score\": 0.908}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 146.384, \"end\": 147.585, \"score\": 0.927}, {\"word\": \"論\"}, {\"word\": \"誰\"}, {\"word\": \"執\"}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 147.585, \"end\": 148.145, \"score\": 0.924}, {\"word\": \"都\", \"start\": 148.145, \"end\": 148.586, \"score\": 0.939}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 148.586, \"end\": 148.866, \"score\": 0.915}, {\"word\": \"如\", \"start\": 148.866, \"end\": 149.266, \"score\": 0.904}, {\"word\": \"此\", \"start\": 149.266, \"end\": 149.847, \"score\": 0.98}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 149.847, \"end\": 150.047, \"score\": 0.918}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 150.047, \"end\": 150.267, \"score\": 0.85}, {\"word\": \"因\", \"start\": 150.267, \"end\": 151.168, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"為\"}, {\"word\": \"現\"}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 151.168, \"end\": 151.708, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"執\"}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 151.708, \"end\": 151.968, \"score\": 0.926}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 151.968, \"end\": 152.188, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 152.188, \"end\": 152.488, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 152.488, \"end\": 153.769, \"score\": 0.886}, {\"word\": \"進\"}, {\"word\": \"黨\"}, {\"word\": \"由\", \"start\": 153.769, \"end\": 154.09, \"score\": 0.963}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 154.09, \"end\": 154.77, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"進\"}, {\"word\": \"黨\"}, {\"word\": \"任\", \"start\": 154.77, \"end\": 154.97, \"score\": 0.906}, {\"word\": \"命\", \"start\": 154.97, \"end\": 155.15, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 155.15, \"end\": 155.351, \"score\": 0.988}, {\"word\": \"主\", \"start\": 155.351, \"end\": 155.691, \"score\": 0.934}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 155.691, \"end\": 156.732, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"臨\"}, {\"word\": \"聘\", \"start\": 156.732, \"end\": 157.092, \"score\": 0.951}, {\"word\": \"而\", \"start\": 157.092, \"end\": 157.712, \"score\": 0.933}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 157.712, \"end\": 158.033, \"score\": 0.947}, {\"word\": \"族\", \"start\": 158.033, \"end\": 158.293, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"群\", \"start\": 158.293, \"end\": 158.513, \"score\": 0.91}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 158.513, \"end\": 159.293, \"score\": 0.948}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"就\", \"start\": 159.293, \"end\": 159.634, \"score\": 0.954}, {\"word\": \"冠\", \"start\": 159.634, \"end\": 159.934, \"score\": 0.978}, {\"word\": \"上\", \"start\": 159.934, \"end\": 160.474, \"score\": 0.907}, {\"word\": \"了\", \"start\": 160.474, \"end\": 160.715, \"score\": 0.872}, {\"word\": \"綠\"}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 160.715, \"end\": 160.955, \"score\": 0.896}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 160.955, \"end\": 161.435, \"score\": 0.935}, {\"word\": \"或\", \"start\": 161.435, \"end\": 161.675, \"score\": 0.899}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 161.675, \"end\": 161.975, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"酬\", \"start\": 161.975, \"end\": 162.296, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"庸\", \"start\": 162.296, \"end\": 162.316, \"score\": 0.001}, {\"word\": \"甚\", \"start\": 162.876, \"end\": 163.096, \"score\": 0.931}, {\"word\": \"至\", \"start\": 163.096, \"end\": 163.336, \"score\": 0.963}, {\"word\": \"倒\", \"start\": 163.336, \"end\": 163.576, \"score\": 0.894}, {\"word\": \"比\", \"start\": 163.576, \"end\": 163.737, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"一\", \"start\": 163.737, \"end\": 164.517, \"score\": 0.974}, {\"word\": \"揮\"}, {\"word\": \"把\", \"start\": 164.517, \"end\": 164.717, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"他\", \"start\": 164.717, \"end\": 165.237, \"score\": 0.953}, {\"word\": \"們\"}, {\"word\": \"服\", \"start\": 165.237, \"end\": 165.678, \"score\": 0.953}, {\"word\": \"務\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 165.678, \"end\": 165.878, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 165.878, \"end\": 166.278, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 166.278, \"end\": 166.518, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"薪\", \"start\": 166.518, \"end\": 167.098, \"score\": 0.931}, {\"word\": \"資\"}, {\"word\": \"都\", \"start\": 167.098, \"end\": 167.779, \"score\": 0.966}, {\"word\": \"砍\"}, {\"word\": \"光\", \"start\": 167.779, \"end\": 168.979, \"score\": 0.96}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"對\"}, {\"word\": \"於\", \"start\": 168.979, \"end\": 169.26, \"score\": 0.929}, {\"word\": \"信\", \"start\": 169.26, \"end\": 169.7, \"score\": 0.924}, {\"word\": \"賴\"}, {\"word\": \"保\", \"start\": 169.7, \"end\": 170.14, \"score\": 0.922}, {\"word\": \"護\"}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 170.14, \"end\": 171.421, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"則\"}, {\"word\": \"存\", \"start\": 171.421, \"end\": 171.781, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 171.781, \"end\": 172.641, \"score\": 0.97}, {\"word\": \"嗎\"}, {\"word\": \"?\"}, {\"word\": \"未\", \"start\": 172.641, \"end\": 173.182, \"score\": 0.962}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"如\", \"start\": 173.182, \"end\": 173.482, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"果\", \"start\": 173.482, \"end\": 173.742, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"提\", \"start\": 173.742, \"end\": 174.042, \"score\": 0.975}, {\"word\": \"起\", \"start\": 174.042, \"end\": 176.323, \"score\": 0.939}, {\"word\": \"訴\"}, {\"word\": \"訟\"}, {\"word\": \"請\"}, {\"word\": \"問\"}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"種\"}, {\"word\": \"責\"}, {\"word\": \"任\", \"start\": 176.323, \"end\": 176.744, \"score\": 0.99}, {\"word\": \"立\", \"start\": 176.744, \"end\": 177.004, \"score\": 0.985}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 177.004, \"end\": 177.204, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"院\", \"start\": 177.204, \"end\": 177.564, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"負\", \"start\": 177.564, \"end\": 177.744, \"score\": 0.789}, {\"word\": \"得\", \"start\": 177.744, \"end\": 177.904, \"score\": 0.886}, {\"word\": \"起\", \"start\": 177.904, \"end\": 178.645, \"score\": 0.963}, {\"word\": \"嗎\"}, {\"word\": \"?\"}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 178.645, \"end\": 179.165, \"score\": 0.887}, {\"word\": \"進\"}, {\"word\": \"黨\"}, {\"word\": \"反\", \"start\": 179.165, \"end\": 179.965, \"score\": 0.949}, {\"word\": \"對\"}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"次\", \"start\": 179.965, \"end\": 180.145, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 180.145, \"end\": 180.326, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 180.326, \"end\": 180.586, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 180.586, \"end\": 182.687, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"謝\"}, {\"word\": \"謝\"}, {\"word\": \"謝\"}, {\"word\": \"謝\"}, {\"word\": \"吳\"}, {\"word\": \"思\", \"start\": 182.687, \"end\": 183.067, \"score\": 0.894}, {\"word\": \"瑤\"}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 183.067, \"end\": 183.627, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"發\"}, {\"word\": \"言\", \"start\": 183.627, \"end\": 183.968, \"score\": 0.983}, {\"word\": \"接\", \"start\": 183.968, \"end\": 184.148, \"score\": 0.947}, {\"word\": \"下\", \"start\": 184.148, \"end\": 185.628, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"請\"}, {\"word\": \"鍾\"}, {\"word\": \"嘉\", \"start\": 185.628, \"end\": 186.009, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"斌\", \"start\": 186.009, \"end\": 186.149, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 186.149, \"end\": 186.529, \"score\": 0.894}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"發\"}, {\"word\": \"言\", \"start\": 186.529, \"end\": 186.689, \"score\": 0.878}, {\"word\": \"李\", \"start\": 186.689, \"end\": 187.049, \"score\": 0.948}, {\"word\": \"柏\", \"start\": 187.049, \"end\": 187.309, \"score\": 0.925}, {\"word\": \"毅\", \"start\": 187.309, \"end\": 187.429, \"score\": 0.833}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 187.429, \"end\": 187.91, \"score\": 0.92}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"請\"}, {\"word\": \"準\", \"start\": 187.91, \"end\": 187.93, \"score\": 0.009}, {\"word\": \"備\"}], \"language\": \"zh\"}","srt":"1\n00:00:00,609 --> 00:00:19,515\n委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳\n\n2\n00:00:21,536 --> 00:00:43,343\n都告訴了我們權力之相互制衡有其界限除了不能抵觸憲法之規定更不能侵犯各個憲法機關的權力核心領域或者對於其他憲法機關權力之行使來造成實質妨害導致責任政治崩壞\n\n3\n00:00:45,104 --> 00:00:59,001\n這都是告訴我們立委要恪遵憲法切莫用修法的方式來介入行政權的人事任命權這一次原住民族組織法的修法重點兩項\n\n4\n00:01:00,643 --> 00:01:29,456\n不管是修法強制要求原住民族的主委要山地、平地來輪流擔任或是現有16位的族群委員由有己職改為無己職這些都是用修法的方式剝奪了憲法賦予行政權的人事任命權限甚至也大大的強害了現有的政務人員信賴保護的原則\n\n5\n00:01:30,496 --> 00:01:54,499\n所以事法性大有問題,合理性當然也應當來審酌我想這樣將山地平地原住民這種殖民時期遺留下來的這種要打破的刻板框架都應當落實在現在立法院的修法思維當中只是非常可惜在野黨委員的提案\n\n6\n00:01:55,180 --> 00:01:55,660\n委員黃秀芳等18人擬具\n\n7\n00:02:16,937 --> 00:02:42,316\n不要分族群這是現在進步的趨勢至於族群委員有幾職的制度數十年來不論誰執政都是如此不要因為現在執政的是民進黨由民進黨任命的主委臨聘而來的族群委員就冠上了綠有有或是酬庸\n\n8\n00:02:42,876 --> 00:03:07,930\n甚至倒比一揮把他們服務人民的薪資都砍光這對於信賴保護原則存在嗎?未來如果提起訴訟請問這種責任立法院負得起嗎?民進黨反對這次的修法謝謝謝謝吳思瑤委員發言接下來請鍾嘉斌委員發言李柏毅委員請準備\n\n","tsv":"start\tend\ttext\n609\t19515\t委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳\n21536\t43343\t都告訴了我們權力之相互制衡有其界限除了不能抵觸憲法之規定更不能侵犯各個憲法機關的權力核心領域或者對於其他憲法機關權力之行使來造成實質妨害導致責任政治崩壞\n45104\t59001\t這都是告訴我們立委要恪遵憲法切莫用修法的方式來介入行政權的人事任命權這一次原住民族組織法的修法重點兩項\n60643\t89456\t不管是修法強制要求原住民族的主委要山地、平地來輪流擔任或是現有16位的族群委員由有己職改為無己職這些都是用修法的方式剝奪了憲法賦予行政權的人事任命權限甚至也大大的強害了現有的政務人員信賴保護的原則\n90496\t114499\t所以事法性大有問題,合理性當然也應當來審酌我想這樣將山地平地原住民這種殖民時期遺留下來的這種要打破的刻板框架都應當落實在現在立法院的修法思維當中只是非常可惜在野黨委員的提案\n115180\t115660\t委員黃秀芳等18人擬具\n136937\t162316\t不要分族群這是現在進步的趨勢至於族群委員有幾職的制度數十年來不論誰執政都是如此不要因為現在執政的是民進黨由民進黨任命的主委臨聘而來的族群委員就冠上了綠有有或是酬庸\n162876\t187930\t甚至倒比一揮把他們服務人民的薪資都砍光這對於信賴保護原則存在嗎?未來如果提起訴訟請問這種責任立法院負得起嗎?民進黨反對這次的修法謝謝謝謝吳思瑤委員發言接下來請鍾嘉斌委員發言李柏毅委員請準備\n","txt":"委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳\n都告訴了我們權力之相互制衡有其界限除了不能抵觸憲法之規定更不能侵犯各個憲法機關的權力核心領域或者對於其他憲法機關權力之行使來造成實質妨害導致責任政治崩壞\n這都是告訴我們立委要恪遵憲法切莫用修法的方式來介入行政權的人事任命權這一次原住民族組織法的修法重點兩項\n不管是修法強制要求原住民族的主委要山地、平地來輪流擔任或是現有16位的族群委員由有己職改為無己職這些都是用修法的方式剝奪了憲法賦予行政權的人事任命權限甚至也大大的強害了現有的政務人員信賴保護的原則\n所以事法性大有問題,合理性當然也應當來審酌我想這樣將山地平地原住民這種殖民時期遺留下來的這種要打破的刻板框架都應當落實在現在立法院的修法思維當中只是非常可惜在野黨委員的提案\n委員黃秀芳等18人擬具\n不要分族群這是現在進步的趨勢至於族群委員有幾職的制度數十年來不論誰執政都是如此不要因為現在執政的是民進黨由民進黨任命的主委臨聘而來的族群委員就冠上了綠有有或是酬庸\n甚至倒比一揮把他們服務人民的薪資都砍光這對於信賴保護原則存在嗎?未來如果提起訴訟請問這種責任立法院負得起嗎?民進黨反對這次的修法謝謝謝謝吳思瑤委員發言接下來請鍾嘉斌委員發言李柏毅委員請準備\n","vtt":"WEBVTT\n\n00:00.609 --> 00:19.515\n委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳\n\n00:21.536 --> 00:43.343\n都告訴了我們權力之相互制衡有其界限除了不能抵觸憲法之規定更不能侵犯各個憲法機關的權力核心領域或者對於其他憲法機關權力之行使來造成實質妨害導致責任政治崩壞\n\n00:45.104 --> 00:59.001\n這都是告訴我們立委要恪遵憲法切莫用修法的方式來介入行政權的人事任命權這一次原住民族組織法的修法重點兩項\n\n01:00.643 --> 01:29.456\n不管是修法強制要求原住民族的主委要山地、平地來輪流擔任或是現有16位的族群委員由有己職改為無己職這些都是用修法的方式剝奪了憲法賦予行政權的人事任命權限甚至也大大的強害了現有的政務人員信賴保護的原則\n\n01:30.496 --> 01:54.499\n所以事法性大有問題,合理性當然也應當來審酌我想這樣將山地平地原住民這種殖民時期遺留下來的這種要打破的刻板框架都應當落實在現在立法院的修法思維當中只是非常可惜在野黨委員的提案\n\n01:55.180 --> 01:55.660\n委員黃秀芳等18人擬具\n\n02:16.937 --> 02:42.316\n不要分族群這是現在進步的趨勢至於族群委員有幾職的制度數十年來不論誰執政都是如此不要因為現在執政的是民進黨由民進黨任命的主委臨聘而來的族群委員就冠上了綠有有或是酬庸\n\n02:42.876 --> 03:07.930\n甚至倒比一揮把他們服務人民的薪資都砍光這對於信賴保護原則存在嗎?未來如果提起訴訟請問這種責任立法院負得起嗎?民進黨反對這次的修法謝謝謝謝吳思瑤委員發言接下來請鍾嘉斌委員發言李柏毅委員請準備\n\n","segments":[{"start":0.609,"end":19.515,"text":"委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳等18人擬具:「學生輔導法部分條文修正草案》、委員黃秀芳"},{"start":21.536,"end":43.343,"text":"都告訴了我們權力之相互制衡有其界限除了不能抵觸憲法之規定更不能侵犯各個憲法機關的權力核心領域或者對於其他憲法機關權力之行使來造成實質妨害導致責任政治崩壞"},{"start":45.104,"end":59.001,"text":"這都是告訴我們立委要恪遵憲法切莫用修法的方式來介入行政權的人事任命權這一次原住民族組織法的修法重點兩項"},{"start":60.643,"end":89.456,"text":"不管是修法強制要求原住民族的主委要山地、平地來輪流擔任或是現有16位的族群委員由有己職改為無己職這些都是用修法的方式剝奪了憲法賦予行政權的人事任命權限甚至也大大的強害了現有的政務人員信賴保護的原則"},{"start":90.496,"end":114.499,"text":"所以事法性大有問題,合理性當然也應當來審酌我想這樣將山地平地原住民這種殖民時期遺留下來的這種要打破的刻板框架都應當落實在現在立法院的修法思維當中只是非常可惜在野黨委員的提案"},{"start":115.18,"end":115.66,"text":"委員黃秀芳等18人擬具"},{"start":136.937,"end":162.316,"text":"不要分族群這是現在進步的趨勢至於族群委員有幾職的制度數十年來不論誰執政都是如此不要因為現在執政的是民進黨由民進黨任命的主委臨聘而來的族群委員就冠上了綠有有或是酬庸"},{"start":162.876,"end":187.93,"text":"甚至倒比一揮把他們服務人民的薪資都砍光這對於信賴保護原則存在嗎?未來如果提起訴訟請問這種責任立法院負得起嗎?民進黨反對這次的修法謝謝謝謝吳思瑤委員發言接下來請鍾嘉斌委員發言李柏毅委員請準備"}]}}},"gazette":{"lineno":141,"blocks":[["吳委員思瑤：（12時28分）主席、各位同仁。立委再大也要恪遵憲法，但非常遺憾，這一屆的立法院卻是最多違憲修法的一屆。人事任命權就是行政權的核心領域，歷次的大法官解釋從釋字第613號、第585號到第391號，都告訴了我們，權力之相互制衡有其界限，除了不能牴觸憲法之規定，更不能侵犯各個憲法機關的權力核心領域，或者對於其他憲法機關權力之行使造成實質妨害，導致責任政治崩壞，這都是告訴我們，立委要恪遵憲法，切莫用修法的方式來介入行政權的人事任命權。","這一次原住民族組織法的修法重點有兩項，不管是修法強制要求原住民族的主委要山地、平地來輪流擔任，或是現有16位族群委員由有給職改為無給職，這些都是用修法的方式剝奪了憲法賦予行政權的人事任命權限，甚至也大大地戕害了現有政務人員信賴保護的原則，所以適法性大有問題，合理性當然也應當來審酌。","我想這樣將山地、平地原住民這種殖民時期遺留下來的要打破的刻板框架，都應當落實在現在立法院的修法思維當中。只是非常可惜，在野黨委員的提案強制地要求輪流讓山地、平地原住民出任，在法律用語上，輪流到底是什麼樣子的機制？在協商的過程，在野委員都沒有辦法清楚來說明，所以用人唯才，不要分你、我、他，不要分族群，這是現在進步的趨勢。","至於族群委員有給職的制度，數十年來不論誰執政都是如此，不要因為現在執政的是民進黨，由民進黨任命的主委遴聘而來的族群委員就灌上了綠友友或是酬庸，甚至大筆一揮，把他們服務人民的薪資都砍光，這對於信賴保護原則存在嗎？未來如果提起訴訟，請問這種責任，立法院負得起嗎？民進黨反對這次的修法，謝謝。"],["主席：謝謝吳思瑤委員發言。","接下來請鍾佳濱委員發言，李柏毅委員請準備。"]],"agenda":{"page_end":92,"meet_id":"院會-11-2-11","speakers":["韓國瑜","江啟臣","羅廷瑋","陳菁徽","張智倫"],"page_start":43,"meetingDate":["2024-11-29"],"gazette_id":"11310201","agenda_lcidc_ids":["11310201_00002","11310201_00003","11310201_00004"],"meet_name":"立法院第11屆第2會期第11次會議紀錄","content":"貨物稅條例修正第十二條條文─ 完成三讀─","agenda_id":"11310201_00004"}}}