{"id":161504,"url":"https://ivod.ly.gov.tw/Play/Clip/1M/161504","video_url":"https://ivod-lyvod.cdn.hinet.net/vod_1/_definst_/mp4:1MClips/fe07dedb5caff746a741aed5090638abb8e2d73ce5d96c5b4ebb0ed34a0e2cbcd6b39e882d62cf0b5ea18f28b6918d91.mp4/playlist.m3u8","委員名稱":"王正旭","委員發言時間":"16:07:56 - 16:10:35","影片長度":"00:02:39","會議時間":"2025-05-16T09:00:00+08:00","會議名稱":"第11屆第3會期第12次會議（事由：一、討論事項：本院委員許宇甄、羅智強、葛如鈞等52人擬具公投提案主文為：「賴清德總統定位對岸為境外敵對勢力，人民擔心兩岸進入準戰爭狀態。你是否同意政府應避免戰爭，不讓台灣變成實施軍事戒嚴、青年喪命且家園被毀的烏克蘭？」請公決案等16案。二、5月16日上午9時至10時為國是論壇時間。三、5月20日下午5時至6時為處理臨時提案時間。）","type":"Clip","date":"2025-05-16","start_time":"2025-05-16T16:07:56+08:00","end_time":"2025-05-16T16:10:35+08:00","duration":159,"meet":{"tmpMeeting":null,"title":"第11屆第3會期第12次會議","id":"院會-11-3-12","type":"院會","term":11,"sessionPeriod":3,"sessionTimes":12},"features":["ai-transcript","gazette"],"transcript":{"id":"161504","pyannote":{"name":"ronny","tool":"pyannote","data":{"url":"https://ivod.ly.gov.tw/Play/Clip/1M/161504","tool":"pyannote","id":"161504-pyannote"},"job_id":"A4CZaCl95q6PUyyQ","queued_at":"2025-05-16 16:29:32","status":"done","log":[{"time":"2025-05-16 16:29:32","msg":"downloading https://ivod.ly.gov.tw/Play/Clip/1M/161504","target":null},{"time":"2025-05-16 16:29:34","msg":"download ivod and merge to wav","target":"/home/conda/test/whisper-api-data/tmp/lyivod-clip-161504.wav"},{"time":"2025-05-16 16:29:39","msg":"running pyannote","target":null},{"time":"2025-05-16 16:29:46","msg":"status: done","target":null}],"result":{"result":[[10.25721875,14.594093750000003,"SPEAKER_00"],[14.982218750000001,26.91284375,"SPEAKER_00"],[27.199718750000002,30.43971875,"SPEAKER_00"],[30.92909375,32.549093750000004,"SPEAKER_00"],[32.93721875,34.337843750000005,"SPEAKER_00"],[34.658468750000004,37.35846875,"SPEAKER_00"],[37.57784375,43.922843750000006,"SPEAKER_00"],[44.159093750000004,57.55784375,"SPEAKER_00"],[57.87846875,60.42659375,"SPEAKER_00"],[60.51096875,63.953468750000006,"SPEAKER_00"],[64.72971875,65.55659375,"SPEAKER_00"],[66.18096875,72.13784375,"SPEAKER_00"],[72.37409375,76.76159375,"SPEAKER_00"],[76.94721875,77.43659375,"SPEAKER_00"],[77.84159375,80.40659375,"SPEAKER_00"],[80.60909375,84.20346875,"SPEAKER_00"],[84.72659375,85.24971875,"SPEAKER_00"],[85.72221875000001,102.95159375,"SPEAKER_00"],[103.33971875,110.34284375,"SPEAKER_00"],[110.76471875,112.19909375,"SPEAKER_00"],[112.80659375,115.08471875000001,"SPEAKER_00"],[115.50659375000001,115.99596875,"SPEAKER_00"],[116.38409375,117.37971875000001,"SPEAKER_00"],[117.44721875,123.10034375000001,"SPEAKER_00"],[123.89346875000001,127.74096875000001,"SPEAKER_00"],[127.89284375000001,130.22159375,"SPEAKER_00"],[130.44096875,131.89221875,"SPEAKER_00"],[132.12846875,134.32221875000002,"SPEAKER_00"],[134.72721875000002,137.24159375000002,"SPEAKER_00"],[137.86596875,140.04284375,"SPEAKER_00"],[140.65034375000002,142.00034375,"SPEAKER_00"],[142.11846875,152.22659375,"SPEAKER_00"],[152.88471875000002,155.34846875000002,"SPEAKER_00"],[155.83784375000002,157.40721875,"SPEAKER_00"]]}},"whisperx":{"name":"ronny","tool":"whisperx","data":{"url":"https://ivod.ly.gov.tw/Play/Clip/1M/161504","tool":"whisperx","id":"161504-whisperx","init_prompt":""},"job_id":"n0aJfjMdNM0HVCsG","queued_at":"2025-05-16 16:29:33","status":"done","log":[{"time":"2025-05-16 16:29:46","msg":"downloading https://ivod.ly.gov.tw/Play/Clip/1M/161504","target":null},{"time":"2025-05-16 16:29:47","msg":"already downloaded","target":"/home/conda/test/whisper-api-data/tmp/lyivod-clip-161504.wav"},{"time":"2025-05-16 16:29:47","msg":"running whisperx with  --language zh --model large-v3","target":null},{"time":"2025-05-16 16:29:59","msg":"merging result","target":null},{"time":"2025-05-16 16:29:59","msg":"status: done","target":null}],"result":{"json":"{\"segments\": [{\"start\": 10.281, \"end\": 14.284, \"text\": \"主席各位議員同仁各位國人同胞大家好\", \"words\": [{\"word\": \"主\", \"start\": 10.281, \"end\": 10.441, \"score\": 0.94}, {\"word\": \"席\", \"start\": 10.441, \"end\": 11.382, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"各\", \"start\": 11.382, \"end\": 11.562, \"score\": 0.888}, {\"word\": \"位\", \"start\": 11.562, \"end\": 12.022, \"score\": 0.87}, {\"word\": \"議\"}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"同\", \"start\": 12.022, \"end\": 12.222, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"仁\", \"start\": 12.222, \"end\": 12.663, \"score\": 0.954}, {\"word\": \"各\", \"start\": 12.663, \"end\": 12.723, \"score\": 0.666}, {\"word\": \"位\", \"start\": 12.723, \"end\": 13.023, \"score\": 0.868}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 13.023, \"end\": 13.143, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"同\", \"start\": 13.143, \"end\": 13.303, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"胞\", \"start\": 13.303, \"end\": 13.924, \"score\": 0.968}, {\"word\": \"大\", \"start\": 13.924, \"end\": 14.044, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"家\", \"start\": 14.044, \"end\": 14.264, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"好\", \"start\": 14.264, \"end\": 14.284, \"score\": 0.92}]}, {\"start\": 15.506, \"end\": 36.757, \"text\": \"針對國民黨所提的今天的公投案我認為在法治上有以下的幾個問題首先依據我國憲法法庭113年憲判制第八號的判決主文第六點就已經寫得非常的清楚科處死刑的判決應經各級法院和議庭法官的一致決\", \"words\": [{\"word\": \"針\"}, {\"word\": \"對\"}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 15.506, \"end\": 15.846, \"score\": 0.94}, {\"word\": \"黨\"}, {\"word\": \"所\", \"start\": 15.846, \"end\": 16.087, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"提\", \"start\": 16.087, \"end\": 16.307, \"score\": 0.922}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 16.307, \"end\": 16.607, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"今\", \"start\": 16.607, \"end\": 16.707, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"天\", \"start\": 16.707, \"end\": 16.847, \"score\": 0.988}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 16.847, \"end\": 16.947, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"公\", \"start\": 16.947, \"end\": 17.127, \"score\": 0.903}, {\"word\": \"投\", \"start\": 17.127, \"end\": 17.287, \"score\": 0.907}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 17.287, \"end\": 17.947, \"score\": 0.995}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 17.947, \"end\": 18.688, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"認\"}, {\"word\": \"為\"}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 18.688, \"end\": 18.908, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 18.908, \"end\": 19.088, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"治\", \"start\": 19.088, \"end\": 19.248, \"score\": 0.883}, {\"word\": \"上\", \"start\": 19.248, \"end\": 19.648, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 19.648, \"end\": 19.808, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"以\", \"start\": 19.808, \"end\": 19.968, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"下\", \"start\": 19.968, \"end\": 20.149, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 20.149, \"end\": 21.349, \"score\": 0.917}, {\"word\": \"幾\"}, {\"word\": \"個\"}, {\"word\": \"問\"}, {\"word\": \"題\"}, {\"word\": \"首\", \"start\": 21.349, \"end\": 21.589, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"先\", \"start\": 21.589, \"end\": 22.29, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"依\", \"start\": 22.29, \"end\": 23.05, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"據\"}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 23.05, \"end\": 23.55, \"score\": 0.91}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 23.55, \"end\": 23.77, \"score\": 0.98}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 23.77, \"end\": 23.95, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"庭\", \"start\": 23.95, \"end\": 24.751, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"3\"}, {\"word\": \"年\", \"start\": 24.751, \"end\": 25.191, \"score\": 0.954}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"判\", \"start\": 25.191, \"end\": 25.391, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 25.391, \"end\": 25.591, \"score\": 0.938}, {\"word\": \"第\", \"start\": 25.591, \"end\": 25.771, \"score\": 0.91}, {\"word\": \"八\", \"start\": 25.771, \"end\": 26.191, \"score\": 0.904}, {\"word\": \"號\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 26.191, \"end\": 26.312, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"判\", \"start\": 26.312, \"end\": 27.272, \"score\": 0.977}, {\"word\": \"決\"}, {\"word\": \"主\", \"start\": 27.272, \"end\": 27.472, \"score\": 0.94}, {\"word\": \"文\", \"start\": 27.472, \"end\": 28.032, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"第\", \"start\": 28.032, \"end\": 28.152, \"score\": 0.879}, {\"word\": \"六\", \"start\": 28.152, \"end\": 28.593, \"score\": 0.956}, {\"word\": \"點\"}, {\"word\": \"就\", \"start\": 28.593, \"end\": 28.753, \"score\": 0.899}, {\"word\": \"已\", \"start\": 28.753, \"end\": 29.213, \"score\": 0.879}, {\"word\": \"經\"}, {\"word\": \"寫\"}, {\"word\": \"得\", \"start\": 29.213, \"end\": 29.413, \"score\": 0.939}, {\"word\": \"非\", \"start\": 29.413, \"end\": 29.613, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"常\", \"start\": 29.613, \"end\": 29.813, \"score\": 0.96}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 29.813, \"end\": 29.933, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"清\", \"start\": 29.933, \"end\": 30.233, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"楚\", \"start\": 30.233, \"end\": 30.974, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"科\", \"start\": 30.974, \"end\": 31.514, \"score\": 0.959}, {\"word\": \"處\"}, {\"word\": \"死\", \"start\": 31.514, \"end\": 31.694, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"刑\", \"start\": 31.694, \"end\": 31.894, \"score\": 0.901}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 31.894, \"end\": 31.994, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"判\", \"start\": 31.994, \"end\": 33.475, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"決\"}, {\"word\": \"應\"}, {\"word\": \"經\"}, {\"word\": \"各\", \"start\": 33.475, \"end\": 33.995, \"score\": 0.941}, {\"word\": \"級\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 33.995, \"end\": 34.756, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"院\", \"start\": 34.756, \"end\": 35.316, \"score\": 0.995}, {\"word\": \"和\", \"start\": 35.316, \"end\": 35.636, \"score\": 0.934}, {\"word\": \"議\"}, {\"word\": \"庭\", \"start\": 35.636, \"end\": 35.856, \"score\": 0.911}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 35.856, \"end\": 36.056, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"官\", \"start\": 36.056, \"end\": 36.376, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 36.376, \"end\": 36.597, \"score\": 0.932}, {\"word\": \"一\", \"start\": 36.597, \"end\": 36.737, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"致\", \"start\": 36.737, \"end\": 36.757, \"score\": 0.027}, {\"word\": \"決\"}]}, {\"start\": 37.757, \"end\": 63.651, \"text\": \"這是非常清楚的事情而且我國是法治國家憲法判決具有具屬全國各機關及人民的效力我想在憲政權利分立及法治國的原則下我們作為立法委員更應該要遵守尊重憲法法庭的判決再來公投的議題屬於法律原則的創制公投必須在\", \"words\": [{\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 37.757, \"end\": 37.897, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"非\", \"start\": 37.897, \"end\": 37.977, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"常\", \"start\": 37.977, \"end\": 38.197, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"清\", \"start\": 38.197, \"end\": 38.417, \"score\": 0.969}, {\"word\": \"楚\", \"start\": 38.417, \"end\": 38.538, \"score\": 0.989}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 38.538, \"end\": 38.738, \"score\": 0.906}, {\"word\": \"事\", \"start\": 38.738, \"end\": 38.938, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"情\", \"start\": 38.938, \"end\": 39.458, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"而\", \"start\": 39.458, \"end\": 39.618, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"且\", \"start\": 39.618, \"end\": 40.038, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 40.038, \"end\": 40.378, \"score\": 0.941}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 40.378, \"end\": 40.579, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 40.579, \"end\": 40.779, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"治\", \"start\": 40.779, \"end\": 41.159, \"score\": 0.895}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"家\", \"start\": 41.159, \"end\": 42.239, \"score\": 0.981}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 42.239, \"end\": 42.5, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"判\", \"start\": 42.5, \"end\": 43.08, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"決\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 43.08, \"end\": 43.26, \"score\": 0.987}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 43.26, \"end\": 43.66, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 43.66, \"end\": 44.301, \"score\": 0.968}, {\"word\": \"屬\"}, {\"word\": \"全\", \"start\": 44.301, \"end\": 45.041, \"score\": 0.973}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"各\", \"start\": 45.041, \"end\": 45.221, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"機\"}, {\"word\": \"關\"}, {\"word\": \"及\", \"start\": 45.221, \"end\": 45.741, \"score\": 0.895}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 45.741, \"end\": 45.901, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 45.901, \"end\": 46.041, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 46.041, \"end\": 46.202, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"效\", \"start\": 46.202, \"end\": 46.442, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"力\", \"start\": 46.442, \"end\": 47.062, \"score\": 0.99}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 47.062, \"end\": 47.222, \"score\": 0.989}, {\"word\": \"想\", \"start\": 47.222, \"end\": 47.762, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 47.762, \"end\": 48.223, \"score\": 0.956}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 48.223, \"end\": 49.003, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"利\", \"start\": 49.003, \"end\": 49.243, \"score\": 0.96}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 49.243, \"end\": 49.403, \"score\": 0.99}, {\"word\": \"立\", \"start\": 49.403, \"end\": 49.963, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"及\", \"start\": 49.963, \"end\": 50.164, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 50.164, \"end\": 50.364, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"治\", \"start\": 50.364, \"end\": 50.644, \"score\": 0.859}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 50.644, \"end\": 50.744, \"score\": 0.951}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 50.744, \"end\": 51.124, \"score\": 0.945}, {\"word\": \"則\"}, {\"word\": \"下\", \"start\": 51.124, \"end\": 51.724, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 51.724, \"end\": 52.245, \"score\": 0.961}, {\"word\": \"們\"}, {\"word\": \"作\", \"start\": 52.245, \"end\": 52.965, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"為\"}, {\"word\": \"立\", \"start\": 52.965, \"end\": 53.185, \"score\": 0.995}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 53.185, \"end\": 53.405, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 53.405, \"end\": 54.166, \"score\": 0.974}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"更\", \"start\": 54.166, \"end\": 54.566, \"score\": 0.9}, {\"word\": \"應\"}, {\"word\": \"該\"}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 54.566, \"end\": 54.746, \"score\": 0.89}, {\"word\": \"遵\", \"start\": 54.746, \"end\": 55.006, \"score\": 0.986}, {\"word\": \"守\", \"start\": 55.006, \"end\": 55.446, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"尊\", \"start\": 55.446, \"end\": 55.666, \"score\": 0.935}, {\"word\": \"重\", \"start\": 55.666, \"end\": 56.227, \"score\": 0.94}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 56.227, \"end\": 56.507, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 56.507, \"end\": 56.687, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"庭\", \"start\": 56.687, \"end\": 56.827, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 56.827, \"end\": 56.947, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"判\", \"start\": 56.947, \"end\": 57.968, \"score\": 0.979}, {\"word\": \"決\"}, {\"word\": \"再\", \"start\": 57.968, \"end\": 58.708, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"公\", \"start\": 58.708, \"end\": 58.888, \"score\": 0.925}, {\"word\": \"投\", \"start\": 58.888, \"end\": 59.028, \"score\": 0.879}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 59.028, \"end\": 60.149, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"議\"}, {\"word\": \"題\"}, {\"word\": \"屬\"}, {\"word\": \"於\", \"start\": 60.149, \"end\": 60.729, \"score\": 0.965}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 60.729, \"end\": 60.929, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"律\", \"start\": 60.929, \"end\": 61.329, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 61.329, \"end\": 61.65, \"score\": 0.937}, {\"word\": \"則\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 61.65, \"end\": 62.07, \"score\": 0.952}, {\"word\": \"創\"}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 62.07, \"end\": 62.51, \"score\": 0.967}, {\"word\": \"公\", \"start\": 62.51, \"end\": 62.73, \"score\": 0.917}, {\"word\": \"投\", \"start\": 62.73, \"end\": 63.25, \"score\": 0.975}, {\"word\": \"必\", \"start\": 63.25, \"end\": 63.631, \"score\": 0.945}, {\"word\": \"須\"}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 63.631, \"end\": 63.651, \"score\": 0.882}]}, {\"start\": 65.058, \"end\": 83.94, \"text\": \"憲法及法律秩序內部進行而且將來相關的政府部門依據公投結果制定的法律不得抵觸大法官憲制及憲法的基本原則所以此案若違背憲法層級的解釋即時通過了相關法律修正亦屬無效\", \"words\": [{\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 65.058, \"end\": 65.259, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"及\", \"start\": 65.259, \"end\": 66.26, \"score\": 0.981}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 66.26, \"end\": 66.42, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"律\", \"start\": 66.42, \"end\": 66.64, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"秩\", \"start\": 66.64, \"end\": 66.82, \"score\": 0.982}, {\"word\": \"序\", \"start\": 66.82, \"end\": 67.281, \"score\": 0.931}, {\"word\": \"內\"}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 67.281, \"end\": 67.641, \"score\": 0.942}, {\"word\": \"進\"}, {\"word\": \"行\", \"start\": 67.641, \"end\": 68.182, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"而\", \"start\": 68.182, \"end\": 68.302, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"且\", \"start\": 68.302, \"end\": 68.983, \"score\": 0.939}, {\"word\": \"將\"}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"相\", \"start\": 68.983, \"end\": 69.343, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"關\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 69.343, \"end\": 69.483, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 69.483, \"end\": 69.684, \"score\": 0.989}, {\"word\": \"府\", \"start\": 69.684, \"end\": 69.884, \"score\": 0.927}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 69.884, \"end\": 70.264, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"門\"}, {\"word\": \"依\", \"start\": 70.264, \"end\": 70.585, \"score\": 0.891}, {\"word\": \"據\"}, {\"word\": \"公\", \"start\": 70.585, \"end\": 70.745, \"score\": 0.877}, {\"word\": \"投\", \"start\": 70.745, \"end\": 71.065, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"結\"}, {\"word\": \"果\", \"start\": 71.065, \"end\": 71.286, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 71.286, \"end\": 71.426, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"定\", \"start\": 71.426, \"end\": 71.546, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 71.546, \"end\": 71.706, \"score\": 0.877}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 71.706, \"end\": 71.906, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"律\", \"start\": 71.906, \"end\": 72.507, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 72.507, \"end\": 72.687, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"得\", \"start\": 72.687, \"end\": 73.208, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"抵\", \"start\": 73.208, \"end\": 73.708, \"score\": 0.955}, {\"word\": \"觸\"}, {\"word\": \"大\", \"start\": 73.708, \"end\": 73.909, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 73.909, \"end\": 74.089, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"官\", \"start\": 74.089, \"end\": 74.629, \"score\": 0.954}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 74.629, \"end\": 74.95, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"及\", \"start\": 74.95, \"end\": 75.631, \"score\": 0.97}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 75.631, \"end\": 75.791, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 75.791, \"end\": 75.931, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"基\", \"start\": 75.931, \"end\": 76.091, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"本\", \"start\": 76.091, \"end\": 76.251, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 76.251, \"end\": 77.072, \"score\": 0.974}, {\"word\": \"則\"}, {\"word\": \"所\", \"start\": 77.072, \"end\": 77.272, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"以\", \"start\": 77.272, \"end\": 77.913, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"此\", \"start\": 77.913, \"end\": 78.033, \"score\": 0.985}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 78.033, \"end\": 78.334, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"若\", \"start\": 78.334, \"end\": 78.734, \"score\": 0.903}, {\"word\": \"違\"}, {\"word\": \"背\", \"start\": 78.734, \"end\": 79.175, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 79.175, \"end\": 79.655, \"score\": 0.917}, {\"word\": \"層\"}, {\"word\": \"級\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 79.655, \"end\": 79.835, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"解\", \"start\": 79.835, \"end\": 80.756, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"釋\"}, {\"word\": \"即\", \"start\": 80.756, \"end\": 81.217, \"score\": 0.915}, {\"word\": \"時\"}, {\"word\": \"通\", \"start\": 81.217, \"end\": 81.637, \"score\": 0.952}, {\"word\": \"過\"}, {\"word\": \"了\", \"start\": 81.637, \"end\": 81.998, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"相\", \"start\": 81.998, \"end\": 82.438, \"score\": 0.954}, {\"word\": \"關\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 82.438, \"end\": 82.599, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"律\", \"start\": 82.599, \"end\": 82.759, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 82.759, \"end\": 82.979, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 82.979, \"end\": 83.259, \"score\": 0.93}, {\"word\": \"亦\", \"start\": 83.259, \"end\": 83.52, \"score\": 0.979}, {\"word\": \"屬\"}, {\"word\": \"無\", \"start\": 83.52, \"end\": 83.92, \"score\": 0.902}, {\"word\": \"效\", \"start\": 83.92, \"end\": 83.94, \"score\": 0.992}]}, {\"start\": 84.781, \"end\": 110.073, \"text\": \"而且合議制度的原則設計本來就是要保障司法判決是多元觀點與慎重考慮尤其在涉及死刑的重大案件上要求法官一致同意才可判處死刑是為了要確保國家不輕率剝奪人民的生命將死刑判決門檻降低至多數決反而可能會導致冤錯案件機率的上升\", \"words\": [{\"word\": \"而\", \"start\": 84.781, \"end\": 84.941, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"且\", \"start\": 84.941, \"end\": 85.741, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"合\", \"start\": 85.741, \"end\": 86.082, \"score\": 0.913}, {\"word\": \"議\"}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 86.082, \"end\": 86.242, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"度\", \"start\": 86.242, \"end\": 86.382, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 86.382, \"end\": 86.482, \"score\": 0.814}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 86.482, \"end\": 87.742, \"score\": 0.947}, {\"word\": \"則\"}, {\"word\": \"設\"}, {\"word\": \"計\"}, {\"word\": \"本\", \"start\": 87.742, \"end\": 88.163, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"就\", \"start\": 88.163, \"end\": 88.303, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 88.303, \"end\": 88.383, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 88.383, \"end\": 88.583, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"保\", \"start\": 88.583, \"end\": 88.763, \"score\": 0.977}, {\"word\": \"障\", \"start\": 88.763, \"end\": 89.023, \"score\": 0.989}, {\"word\": \"司\", \"start\": 89.023, \"end\": 89.183, \"score\": 0.902}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 89.183, \"end\": 89.423, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"判\", \"start\": 89.423, \"end\": 89.823, \"score\": 0.945}, {\"word\": \"決\"}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 89.823, \"end\": 90.003, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"多\", \"start\": 90.003, \"end\": 90.204, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"元\", \"start\": 90.204, \"end\": 91.464, \"score\": 0.926}, {\"word\": \"觀\"}, {\"word\": \"點\"}, {\"word\": \"與\"}, {\"word\": \"慎\"}, {\"word\": \"重\", \"start\": 91.464, \"end\": 91.684, \"score\": 0.927}, {\"word\": \"考\", \"start\": 91.684, \"end\": 92.385, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"慮\"}, {\"word\": \"尤\", \"start\": 92.385, \"end\": 92.545, \"score\": 0.907}, {\"word\": \"其\", \"start\": 92.545, \"end\": 92.685, \"score\": 0.921}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 92.685, \"end\": 93.005, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"涉\", \"start\": 93.005, \"end\": 93.205, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"及\", \"start\": 93.205, \"end\": 93.525, \"score\": 0.921}, {\"word\": \"死\", \"start\": 93.525, \"end\": 93.725, \"score\": 0.906}, {\"word\": \"刑\", \"start\": 93.725, \"end\": 93.885, \"score\": 0.892}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 93.885, \"end\": 94.065, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"重\", \"start\": 94.065, \"end\": 94.265, \"score\": 0.977}, {\"word\": \"大\", \"start\": 94.265, \"end\": 94.426, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 94.426, \"end\": 94.586, \"score\": 0.982}, {\"word\": \"件\", \"start\": 94.586, \"end\": 94.806, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"上\", \"start\": 94.806, \"end\": 95.366, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 95.366, \"end\": 95.646, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"求\", \"start\": 95.646, \"end\": 95.966, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 95.966, \"end\": 96.166, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"官\", \"start\": 96.166, \"end\": 96.487, \"score\": 0.979}, {\"word\": \"一\", \"start\": 96.487, \"end\": 96.647, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"致\", \"start\": 96.647, \"end\": 96.827, \"score\": 0.916}, {\"word\": \"同\", \"start\": 96.827, \"end\": 97.047, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"意\", \"start\": 97.047, \"end\": 97.427, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"才\", \"start\": 97.427, \"end\": 97.607, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"可\", \"start\": 97.607, \"end\": 97.807, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"判\", \"start\": 97.807, \"end\": 98.267, \"score\": 0.951}, {\"word\": \"處\"}, {\"word\": \"死\", \"start\": 98.267, \"end\": 98.487, \"score\": 0.91}, {\"word\": \"刑\", \"start\": 98.487, \"end\": 98.708, \"score\": 0.92}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 98.708, \"end\": 98.968, \"score\": 0.908}, {\"word\": \"為\"}, {\"word\": \"了\", \"start\": 98.968, \"end\": 99.048, \"score\": 0.951}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 99.048, \"end\": 99.488, \"score\": 0.954}, {\"word\": \"確\"}, {\"word\": \"保\", \"start\": 99.488, \"end\": 99.888, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"家\", \"start\": 99.888, \"end\": 100.408, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 100.408, \"end\": 100.829, \"score\": 0.952}, {\"word\": \"輕\"}, {\"word\": \"率\", \"start\": 100.829, \"end\": 102.029, \"score\": 0.958}, {\"word\": \"剝\"}, {\"word\": \"奪\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 102.029, \"end\": 102.189, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 102.189, \"end\": 102.389, \"score\": 0.985}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 102.389, \"end\": 102.529, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 102.529, \"end\": 102.729, \"score\": 0.963}, {\"word\": \"命\", \"start\": 102.729, \"end\": 103.67, \"score\": 0.978}, {\"word\": \"將\"}, {\"word\": \"死\", \"start\": 103.67, \"end\": 103.83, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"刑\", \"start\": 103.83, \"end\": 104.05, \"score\": 0.919}, {\"word\": \"判\", \"start\": 104.05, \"end\": 105.031, \"score\": 0.938}, {\"word\": \"決\"}, {\"word\": \"門\"}, {\"word\": \"檻\"}, {\"word\": \"降\", \"start\": 105.031, \"end\": 105.271, \"score\": 0.938}, {\"word\": \"低\", \"start\": 105.271, \"end\": 105.411, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"至\", \"start\": 105.411, \"end\": 105.651, \"score\": 0.919}, {\"word\": \"多\", \"start\": 105.651, \"end\": 106.671, \"score\": 0.961}, {\"word\": \"數\"}, {\"word\": \"決\"}, {\"word\": \"反\", \"start\": 106.671, \"end\": 106.811, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"而\", \"start\": 106.811, \"end\": 107.071, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"可\", \"start\": 107.071, \"end\": 107.312, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"能\", \"start\": 107.312, \"end\": 107.852, \"score\": 0.89}, {\"word\": \"會\"}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"致\", \"start\": 107.852, \"end\": 108.052, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"冤\", \"start\": 108.052, \"end\": 108.532, \"score\": 0.942}, {\"word\": \"錯\"}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 108.532, \"end\": 108.772, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"件\", \"start\": 108.772, \"end\": 109.473, \"score\": 0.951}, {\"word\": \"機\"}, {\"word\": \"率\", \"start\": 109.473, \"end\": 109.613, \"score\": 0.858}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 109.613, \"end\": 109.773, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"上\", \"start\": 109.773, \"end\": 110.053, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"升\", \"start\": 110.053, \"end\": 110.073, \"score\": 0.432}]}, {\"start\": 111.014, \"end\": 139.486, \"text\": \"違背程序正義進而損害司法的信賴最後 死刑議題關係到最基本的人權的保障不應該被簡化為政治動員的手段死刑是一種國家權利對生命的最終剝奪應該有最嚴格的程序保障國民黨此次公投案試圖鬆綁司法合一的制度降低國家殺人的門檻\", \"words\": [{\"word\": \"違\"}, {\"word\": \"背\", \"start\": 111.014, \"end\": 111.334, \"score\": 0.937}, {\"word\": \"程\", \"start\": 111.334, \"end\": 111.554, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"序\", \"start\": 111.554, \"end\": 111.794, \"score\": 0.984}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 111.794, \"end\": 113.015, \"score\": 0.954}, {\"word\": \"義\"}, {\"word\": \"進\"}, {\"word\": \"而\", \"start\": 113.015, \"end\": 113.715, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"損\"}, {\"word\": \"害\", \"start\": 113.715, \"end\": 114.075, \"score\": 0.989}, {\"word\": \"司\", \"start\": 114.075, \"end\": 114.315, \"score\": 0.952}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 114.315, \"end\": 114.455, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 114.455, \"end\": 114.596, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"信\", \"start\": 114.596, \"end\": 115.556, \"score\": 0.973}, {\"word\": \"賴\"}, {\"word\": \"最\", \"start\": 115.556, \"end\": 115.736, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"後\", \"start\": 115.736, \"end\": 116.436, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"死\", \"start\": 116.436, \"end\": 116.596, \"score\": 0.883}, {\"word\": \"刑\", \"start\": 116.596, \"end\": 117.937, \"score\": 0.925}, {\"word\": \"議\"}, {\"word\": \"題\"}, {\"word\": \"關\"}, {\"word\": \"係\"}, {\"word\": \"到\", \"start\": 117.937, \"end\": 118.217, \"score\": 0.928}, {\"word\": \"最\", \"start\": 118.217, \"end\": 118.397, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"基\", \"start\": 118.397, \"end\": 118.617, \"score\": 0.99}, {\"word\": \"本\", \"start\": 118.617, \"end\": 118.757, \"score\": 0.989}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 118.757, \"end\": 118.917, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 118.917, \"end\": 119.317, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 119.317, \"end\": 119.437, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"保\", \"start\": 119.437, \"end\": 119.638, \"score\": 0.941}, {\"word\": \"障\", \"start\": 119.638, \"end\": 120.158, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 120.158, \"end\": 120.638, \"score\": 0.916}, {\"word\": \"應\"}, {\"word\": \"該\"}, {\"word\": \"被\", \"start\": 120.638, \"end\": 121.118, \"score\": 0.958}, {\"word\": \"簡\"}, {\"word\": \"化\", \"start\": 121.118, \"end\": 121.578, \"score\": 0.942}, {\"word\": \"為\"}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 121.578, \"end\": 121.838, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"治\", \"start\": 121.838, \"end\": 122.499, \"score\": 0.924}, {\"word\": \"動\"}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 122.499, \"end\": 122.639, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"手\", \"start\": 122.639, \"end\": 122.859, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"段\", \"start\": 122.859, \"end\": 123.959, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"死\", \"start\": 123.959, \"end\": 124.139, \"score\": 0.895}, {\"word\": \"刑\", \"start\": 124.139, \"end\": 124.66, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 124.66, \"end\": 124.78, \"score\": 0.836}, {\"word\": \"一\", \"start\": 124.78, \"end\": 125.26, \"score\": 0.917}, {\"word\": \"種\"}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"家\", \"start\": 125.26, \"end\": 125.68, \"score\": 0.952}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"利\", \"start\": 125.68, \"end\": 126.08, \"score\": 0.855}, {\"word\": \"對\"}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 126.08, \"end\": 126.28, \"score\": 0.963}, {\"word\": \"命\", \"start\": 126.28, \"end\": 126.48, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 126.48, \"end\": 126.74, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"最\", \"start\": 126.74, \"end\": 128.341, \"score\": 0.937}, {\"word\": \"終\"}, {\"word\": \"剝\"}, {\"word\": \"奪\"}, {\"word\": \"應\"}, {\"word\": \"該\"}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 128.341, \"end\": 128.541, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"最\", \"start\": 128.541, \"end\": 128.961, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"嚴\"}, {\"word\": \"格\", \"start\": 128.961, \"end\": 129.101, \"score\": 0.974}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 129.101, \"end\": 129.221, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"程\", \"start\": 129.221, \"end\": 129.442, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"序\", \"start\": 129.442, \"end\": 129.642, \"score\": 0.983}, {\"word\": \"保\", \"start\": 129.642, \"end\": 129.862, \"score\": 0.953}, {\"word\": \"障\", \"start\": 129.862, \"end\": 130.682, \"score\": 0.974}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 130.682, \"end\": 131.342, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"黨\"}, {\"word\": \"此\", \"start\": 131.342, \"end\": 131.562, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"次\", \"start\": 131.562, \"end\": 132.243, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"公\", \"start\": 132.243, \"end\": 132.423, \"score\": 0.903}, {\"word\": \"投\", \"start\": 132.423, \"end\": 132.583, \"score\": 0.882}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 132.583, \"end\": 135.944, \"score\": 0.962}, {\"word\": \"試\"}, {\"word\": \"圖\"}, {\"word\": \"鬆\"}, {\"word\": \"綁\"}, {\"word\": \"司\", \"start\": 135.944, \"end\": 136.104, \"score\": 0.948}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 136.104, \"end\": 136.384, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"合\", \"start\": 136.384, \"end\": 136.564, \"score\": 0.995}, {\"word\": \"一\", \"start\": 136.564, \"end\": 136.664, \"score\": 0.799}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 136.664, \"end\": 136.824, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 136.824, \"end\": 137.005, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"度\", \"start\": 137.005, \"end\": 137.925, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"降\", \"start\": 137.925, \"end\": 138.245, \"score\": 0.981}, {\"word\": \"低\", \"start\": 138.245, \"end\": 138.865, \"score\": 0.967}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"家\", \"start\": 138.865, \"end\": 139.345, \"score\": 0.958}, {\"word\": \"殺\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 139.345, \"end\": 139.466, \"score\": 0.995}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 139.466, \"end\": 139.486, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"門\"}, {\"word\": \"檻\"}]}, {\"start\": 141.707, \"end\": 157.162, \"text\": \"違憲違法違反情理實不可取我們呼籲全國國人基於對生命尊嚴的尊重對憲政體制的捍衛拒絕此一違憲背離司法正義的公投提案大罷免大成功\", \"words\": [{\"word\": \"違\"}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"違\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 141.707, \"end\": 142.448, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"違\"}, {\"word\": \"反\", \"start\": 142.448, \"end\": 142.688, \"score\": 0.99}, {\"word\": \"情\", \"start\": 142.688, \"end\": 142.948, \"score\": 0.987}, {\"word\": \"理\", \"start\": 142.948, \"end\": 143.529, \"score\": 0.956}, {\"word\": \"實\"}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 143.529, \"end\": 143.609, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"可\", \"start\": 143.609, \"end\": 143.869, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"取\", \"start\": 143.869, \"end\": 144.35, \"score\": 0.965}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 144.35, \"end\": 144.63, \"score\": 0.928}, {\"word\": \"們\"}, {\"word\": \"呼\", \"start\": 144.63, \"end\": 145.31, \"score\": 0.968}, {\"word\": \"籲\"}, {\"word\": \"全\", \"start\": 145.31, \"end\": 145.891, \"score\": 0.931}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 145.891, \"end\": 146.411, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"基\", \"start\": 146.411, \"end\": 146.552, \"score\": 0.98}, {\"word\": \"於\", \"start\": 146.552, \"end\": 146.992, \"score\": 0.91}, {\"word\": \"對\"}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 146.992, \"end\": 147.192, \"score\": 0.963}, {\"word\": \"命\", \"start\": 147.192, \"end\": 147.733, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"尊\", \"start\": 147.733, \"end\": 148.073, \"score\": 0.932}, {\"word\": \"嚴\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 148.073, \"end\": 148.213, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"尊\", \"start\": 148.213, \"end\": 148.453, \"score\": 0.983}, {\"word\": \"重\", \"start\": 148.453, \"end\": 149.394, \"score\": 0.939}, {\"word\": \"對\"}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 149.394, \"end\": 149.835, \"score\": 0.934}, {\"word\": \"體\"}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 149.835, \"end\": 149.955, \"score\": 0.85}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 149.955, \"end\": 150.055, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"捍\", \"start\": 150.055, \"end\": 150.856, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"衛\"}, {\"word\": \"拒\", \"start\": 150.856, \"end\": 151.396, \"score\": 0.962}, {\"word\": \"絕\"}, {\"word\": \"此\", \"start\": 151.396, \"end\": 151.496, \"score\": 0.825}, {\"word\": \"一\", \"start\": 151.496, \"end\": 152.938, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"違\"}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"背\", \"start\": 152.938, \"end\": 153.398, \"score\": 0.916}, {\"word\": \"離\"}, {\"word\": \"司\", \"start\": 153.398, \"end\": 153.558, \"score\": 0.891}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 153.558, \"end\": 153.798, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 153.798, \"end\": 154.119, \"score\": 0.927}, {\"word\": \"義\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 154.119, \"end\": 154.439, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"公\", \"start\": 154.439, \"end\": 154.679, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"投\", \"start\": 154.679, \"end\": 154.939, \"score\": 0.935}, {\"word\": \"提\", \"start\": 154.939, \"end\": 155.08, \"score\": 0.99}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 155.08, \"end\": 155.92, \"score\": 0.995}, {\"word\": \"大\", \"start\": 155.92, \"end\": 156.261, \"score\": 0.941}, {\"word\": \"罷\"}, {\"word\": \"免\", \"start\": 156.261, \"end\": 156.801, \"score\": 0.988}, {\"word\": \"大\", \"start\": 156.801, \"end\": 156.941, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"成\", \"start\": 156.941, \"end\": 157.142, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"功\", \"start\": 157.142, \"end\": 157.162, \"score\": 0.829}]}], \"word_segments\": [{\"word\": \"主\", \"start\": 10.281, \"end\": 10.441, \"score\": 0.94}, {\"word\": \"席\", \"start\": 10.441, \"end\": 11.382, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"各\", \"start\": 11.382, \"end\": 11.562, \"score\": 0.888}, {\"word\": \"位\", \"start\": 11.562, \"end\": 12.022, \"score\": 0.87}, {\"word\": \"議\"}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"同\", \"start\": 12.022, \"end\": 12.222, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"仁\", \"start\": 12.222, \"end\": 12.663, \"score\": 0.954}, {\"word\": \"各\", \"start\": 12.663, \"end\": 12.723, \"score\": 0.666}, {\"word\": \"位\", \"start\": 12.723, \"end\": 13.023, \"score\": 0.868}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 13.023, \"end\": 13.143, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"同\", \"start\": 13.143, \"end\": 13.303, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"胞\", \"start\": 13.303, \"end\": 13.924, \"score\": 0.968}, {\"word\": \"大\", \"start\": 13.924, \"end\": 14.044, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"家\", \"start\": 14.044, \"end\": 14.264, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"好\", \"start\": 14.264, \"end\": 14.284, \"score\": 0.92}, {\"word\": \"針\"}, {\"word\": \"對\"}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 15.506, \"end\": 15.846, \"score\": 0.94}, {\"word\": \"黨\"}, {\"word\": \"所\", \"start\": 15.846, \"end\": 16.087, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"提\", \"start\": 16.087, \"end\": 16.307, \"score\": 0.922}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 16.307, \"end\": 16.607, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"今\", \"start\": 16.607, \"end\": 16.707, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"天\", \"start\": 16.707, \"end\": 16.847, \"score\": 0.988}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 16.847, \"end\": 16.947, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"公\", \"start\": 16.947, \"end\": 17.127, \"score\": 0.903}, {\"word\": \"投\", \"start\": 17.127, \"end\": 17.287, \"score\": 0.907}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 17.287, \"end\": 17.947, \"score\": 0.995}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 17.947, \"end\": 18.688, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"認\"}, {\"word\": \"為\"}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 18.688, \"end\": 18.908, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 18.908, \"end\": 19.088, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"治\", \"start\": 19.088, \"end\": 19.248, \"score\": 0.883}, {\"word\": \"上\", \"start\": 19.248, \"end\": 19.648, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 19.648, \"end\": 19.808, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"以\", \"start\": 19.808, \"end\": 19.968, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"下\", \"start\": 19.968, \"end\": 20.149, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 20.149, \"end\": 21.349, \"score\": 0.917}, {\"word\": \"幾\"}, {\"word\": \"個\"}, {\"word\": \"問\"}, {\"word\": \"題\"}, {\"word\": \"首\", \"start\": 21.349, \"end\": 21.589, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"先\", \"start\": 21.589, \"end\": 22.29, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"依\", \"start\": 22.29, \"end\": 23.05, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"據\"}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 23.05, \"end\": 23.55, \"score\": 0.91}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 23.55, \"end\": 23.77, \"score\": 0.98}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 23.77, \"end\": 23.95, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"庭\", \"start\": 23.95, \"end\": 24.751, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"1\"}, {\"word\": \"3\"}, {\"word\": \"年\", \"start\": 24.751, \"end\": 25.191, \"score\": 0.954}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"判\", \"start\": 25.191, \"end\": 25.391, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 25.391, \"end\": 25.591, \"score\": 0.938}, {\"word\": \"第\", \"start\": 25.591, \"end\": 25.771, \"score\": 0.91}, {\"word\": \"八\", \"start\": 25.771, \"end\": 26.191, \"score\": 0.904}, {\"word\": \"號\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 26.191, \"end\": 26.312, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"判\", \"start\": 26.312, \"end\": 27.272, \"score\": 0.977}, {\"word\": \"決\"}, {\"word\": \"主\", \"start\": 27.272, \"end\": 27.472, \"score\": 0.94}, {\"word\": \"文\", \"start\": 27.472, \"end\": 28.032, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"第\", \"start\": 28.032, \"end\": 28.152, \"score\": 0.879}, {\"word\": \"六\", \"start\": 28.152, \"end\": 28.593, \"score\": 0.956}, {\"word\": \"點\"}, {\"word\": \"就\", \"start\": 28.593, \"end\": 28.753, \"score\": 0.899}, {\"word\": \"已\", \"start\": 28.753, \"end\": 29.213, \"score\": 0.879}, {\"word\": \"經\"}, {\"word\": \"寫\"}, {\"word\": \"得\", \"start\": 29.213, \"end\": 29.413, \"score\": 0.939}, {\"word\": \"非\", \"start\": 29.413, \"end\": 29.613, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"常\", \"start\": 29.613, \"end\": 29.813, \"score\": 0.96}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 29.813, \"end\": 29.933, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"清\", \"start\": 29.933, \"end\": 30.233, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"楚\", \"start\": 30.233, \"end\": 30.974, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"科\", \"start\": 30.974, \"end\": 31.514, \"score\": 0.959}, {\"word\": \"處\"}, {\"word\": \"死\", \"start\": 31.514, \"end\": 31.694, \"score\": 0.889}, {\"word\": \"刑\", \"start\": 31.694, \"end\": 31.894, \"score\": 0.901}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 31.894, \"end\": 31.994, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"判\", \"start\": 31.994, \"end\": 33.475, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"決\"}, {\"word\": \"應\"}, {\"word\": \"經\"}, {\"word\": \"各\", \"start\": 33.475, \"end\": 33.995, \"score\": 0.941}, {\"word\": \"級\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 33.995, \"end\": 34.756, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"院\", \"start\": 34.756, \"end\": 35.316, \"score\": 0.995}, {\"word\": \"和\", \"start\": 35.316, \"end\": 35.636, \"score\": 0.934}, {\"word\": \"議\"}, {\"word\": \"庭\", \"start\": 35.636, \"end\": 35.856, \"score\": 0.911}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 35.856, \"end\": 36.056, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"官\", \"start\": 36.056, \"end\": 36.376, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 36.376, \"end\": 36.597, \"score\": 0.932}, {\"word\": \"一\", \"start\": 36.597, \"end\": 36.737, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"致\", \"start\": 36.737, \"end\": 36.757, \"score\": 0.027}, {\"word\": \"決\"}, {\"word\": \"這\"}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 37.757, \"end\": 37.897, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"非\", \"start\": 37.897, \"end\": 37.977, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"常\", \"start\": 37.977, \"end\": 38.197, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"清\", \"start\": 38.197, \"end\": 38.417, \"score\": 0.969}, {\"word\": \"楚\", \"start\": 38.417, \"end\": 38.538, \"score\": 0.989}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 38.538, \"end\": 38.738, \"score\": 0.906}, {\"word\": \"事\", \"start\": 38.738, \"end\": 38.938, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"情\", \"start\": 38.938, \"end\": 39.458, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"而\", \"start\": 39.458, \"end\": 39.618, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"且\", \"start\": 39.618, \"end\": 40.038, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 40.038, \"end\": 40.378, \"score\": 0.941}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 40.378, \"end\": 40.579, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 40.579, \"end\": 40.779, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"治\", \"start\": 40.779, \"end\": 41.159, \"score\": 0.895}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"家\", \"start\": 41.159, \"end\": 42.239, \"score\": 0.981}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 42.239, \"end\": 42.5, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"判\", \"start\": 42.5, \"end\": 43.08, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"決\"}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 43.08, \"end\": 43.26, \"score\": 0.987}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 43.26, \"end\": 43.66, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"具\", \"start\": 43.66, \"end\": 44.301, \"score\": 0.968}, {\"word\": \"屬\"}, {\"word\": \"全\", \"start\": 44.301, \"end\": 45.041, \"score\": 0.973}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"各\", \"start\": 45.041, \"end\": 45.221, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"機\"}, {\"word\": \"關\"}, {\"word\": \"及\", \"start\": 45.221, \"end\": 45.741, \"score\": 0.895}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 45.741, \"end\": 45.901, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 45.901, \"end\": 46.041, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 46.041, \"end\": 46.202, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"效\", \"start\": 46.202, \"end\": 46.442, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"力\", \"start\": 46.442, \"end\": 47.062, \"score\": 0.99}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 47.062, \"end\": 47.222, \"score\": 0.989}, {\"word\": \"想\", \"start\": 47.222, \"end\": 47.762, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 47.762, \"end\": 48.223, \"score\": 0.956}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 48.223, \"end\": 49.003, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"利\", \"start\": 49.003, \"end\": 49.243, \"score\": 0.96}, {\"word\": \"分\", \"start\": 49.243, \"end\": 49.403, \"score\": 0.99}, {\"word\": \"立\", \"start\": 49.403, \"end\": 49.963, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"及\", \"start\": 49.963, \"end\": 50.164, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 50.164, \"end\": 50.364, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"治\", \"start\": 50.364, \"end\": 50.644, \"score\": 0.859}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 50.644, \"end\": 50.744, \"score\": 0.951}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 50.744, \"end\": 51.124, \"score\": 0.945}, {\"word\": \"則\"}, {\"word\": \"下\", \"start\": 51.124, \"end\": 51.724, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 51.724, \"end\": 52.245, \"score\": 0.961}, {\"word\": \"們\"}, {\"word\": \"作\", \"start\": 52.245, \"end\": 52.965, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"為\"}, {\"word\": \"立\", \"start\": 52.965, \"end\": 53.185, \"score\": 0.995}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 53.185, \"end\": 53.405, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"委\", \"start\": 53.405, \"end\": 54.166, \"score\": 0.974}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"更\", \"start\": 54.166, \"end\": 54.566, \"score\": 0.9}, {\"word\": \"應\"}, {\"word\": \"該\"}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 54.566, \"end\": 54.746, \"score\": 0.89}, {\"word\": \"遵\", \"start\": 54.746, \"end\": 55.006, \"score\": 0.986}, {\"word\": \"守\", \"start\": 55.006, \"end\": 55.446, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"尊\", \"start\": 55.446, \"end\": 55.666, \"score\": 0.935}, {\"word\": \"重\", \"start\": 55.666, \"end\": 56.227, \"score\": 0.94}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 56.227, \"end\": 56.507, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 56.507, \"end\": 56.687, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"庭\", \"start\": 56.687, \"end\": 56.827, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 56.827, \"end\": 56.947, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"判\", \"start\": 56.947, \"end\": 57.968, \"score\": 0.979}, {\"word\": \"決\"}, {\"word\": \"再\", \"start\": 57.968, \"end\": 58.708, \"score\": 0.957}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"公\", \"start\": 58.708, \"end\": 58.888, \"score\": 0.925}, {\"word\": \"投\", \"start\": 58.888, \"end\": 59.028, \"score\": 0.879}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 59.028, \"end\": 60.149, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"議\"}, {\"word\": \"題\"}, {\"word\": \"屬\"}, {\"word\": \"於\", \"start\": 60.149, \"end\": 60.729, \"score\": 0.965}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 60.729, \"end\": 60.929, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"律\", \"start\": 60.929, \"end\": 61.329, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 61.329, \"end\": 61.65, \"score\": 0.937}, {\"word\": \"則\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 61.65, \"end\": 62.07, \"score\": 0.952}, {\"word\": \"創\"}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 62.07, \"end\": 62.51, \"score\": 0.967}, {\"word\": \"公\", \"start\": 62.51, \"end\": 62.73, \"score\": 0.917}, {\"word\": \"投\", \"start\": 62.73, \"end\": 63.25, \"score\": 0.975}, {\"word\": \"必\", \"start\": 63.25, \"end\": 63.631, \"score\": 0.945}, {\"word\": \"須\"}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 63.631, \"end\": 63.651, \"score\": 0.882}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 65.058, \"end\": 65.259, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"及\", \"start\": 65.259, \"end\": 66.26, \"score\": 0.981}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 66.26, \"end\": 66.42, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"律\", \"start\": 66.42, \"end\": 66.64, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"秩\", \"start\": 66.64, \"end\": 66.82, \"score\": 0.982}, {\"word\": \"序\", \"start\": 66.82, \"end\": 67.281, \"score\": 0.931}, {\"word\": \"內\"}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 67.281, \"end\": 67.641, \"score\": 0.942}, {\"word\": \"進\"}, {\"word\": \"行\", \"start\": 67.641, \"end\": 68.182, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"而\", \"start\": 68.182, \"end\": 68.302, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"且\", \"start\": 68.302, \"end\": 68.983, \"score\": 0.939}, {\"word\": \"將\"}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"相\", \"start\": 68.983, \"end\": 69.343, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"關\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 69.343, \"end\": 69.483, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 69.483, \"end\": 69.684, \"score\": 0.989}, {\"word\": \"府\", \"start\": 69.684, \"end\": 69.884, \"score\": 0.927}, {\"word\": \"部\", \"start\": 69.884, \"end\": 70.264, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"門\"}, {\"word\": \"依\", \"start\": 70.264, \"end\": 70.585, \"score\": 0.891}, {\"word\": \"據\"}, {\"word\": \"公\", \"start\": 70.585, \"end\": 70.745, \"score\": 0.877}, {\"word\": \"投\", \"start\": 70.745, \"end\": 71.065, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"結\"}, {\"word\": \"果\", \"start\": 71.065, \"end\": 71.286, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 71.286, \"end\": 71.426, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"定\", \"start\": 71.426, \"end\": 71.546, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 71.546, \"end\": 71.706, \"score\": 0.877}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 71.706, \"end\": 71.906, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"律\", \"start\": 71.906, \"end\": 72.507, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 72.507, \"end\": 72.687, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"得\", \"start\": 72.687, \"end\": 73.208, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"抵\", \"start\": 73.208, \"end\": 73.708, \"score\": 0.955}, {\"word\": \"觸\"}, {\"word\": \"大\", \"start\": 73.708, \"end\": 73.909, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 73.909, \"end\": 74.089, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"官\", \"start\": 74.089, \"end\": 74.629, \"score\": 0.954}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 74.629, \"end\": 74.95, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"及\", \"start\": 74.95, \"end\": 75.631, \"score\": 0.97}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 75.631, \"end\": 75.791, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 75.791, \"end\": 75.931, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"基\", \"start\": 75.931, \"end\": 76.091, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"本\", \"start\": 76.091, \"end\": 76.251, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 76.251, \"end\": 77.072, \"score\": 0.974}, {\"word\": \"則\"}, {\"word\": \"所\", \"start\": 77.072, \"end\": 77.272, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"以\", \"start\": 77.272, \"end\": 77.913, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"此\", \"start\": 77.913, \"end\": 78.033, \"score\": 0.985}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 78.033, \"end\": 78.334, \"score\": 0.997}, {\"word\": \"若\", \"start\": 78.334, \"end\": 78.734, \"score\": 0.903}, {\"word\": \"違\"}, {\"word\": \"背\", \"start\": 78.734, \"end\": 79.175, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 79.175, \"end\": 79.655, \"score\": 0.917}, {\"word\": \"層\"}, {\"word\": \"級\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 79.655, \"end\": 79.835, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"解\", \"start\": 79.835, \"end\": 80.756, \"score\": 0.976}, {\"word\": \"釋\"}, {\"word\": \"即\", \"start\": 80.756, \"end\": 81.217, \"score\": 0.915}, {\"word\": \"時\"}, {\"word\": \"通\", \"start\": 81.217, \"end\": 81.637, \"score\": 0.952}, {\"word\": \"過\"}, {\"word\": \"了\", \"start\": 81.637, \"end\": 81.998, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"相\", \"start\": 81.998, \"end\": 82.438, \"score\": 0.954}, {\"word\": \"關\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 82.438, \"end\": 82.599, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"律\", \"start\": 82.599, \"end\": 82.759, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"修\", \"start\": 82.759, \"end\": 82.979, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 82.979, \"end\": 83.259, \"score\": 0.93}, {\"word\": \"亦\", \"start\": 83.259, \"end\": 83.52, \"score\": 0.979}, {\"word\": \"屬\"}, {\"word\": \"無\", \"start\": 83.52, \"end\": 83.92, \"score\": 0.902}, {\"word\": \"效\", \"start\": 83.92, \"end\": 83.94, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"而\", \"start\": 84.781, \"end\": 84.941, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"且\", \"start\": 84.941, \"end\": 85.741, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"合\", \"start\": 85.741, \"end\": 86.082, \"score\": 0.913}, {\"word\": \"議\"}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 86.082, \"end\": 86.242, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"度\", \"start\": 86.242, \"end\": 86.382, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 86.382, \"end\": 86.482, \"score\": 0.814}, {\"word\": \"原\", \"start\": 86.482, \"end\": 87.742, \"score\": 0.947}, {\"word\": \"則\"}, {\"word\": \"設\"}, {\"word\": \"計\"}, {\"word\": \"本\", \"start\": 87.742, \"end\": 88.163, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"來\"}, {\"word\": \"就\", \"start\": 88.163, \"end\": 88.303, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 88.303, \"end\": 88.383, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 88.383, \"end\": 88.583, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"保\", \"start\": 88.583, \"end\": 88.763, \"score\": 0.977}, {\"word\": \"障\", \"start\": 88.763, \"end\": 89.023, \"score\": 0.989}, {\"word\": \"司\", \"start\": 89.023, \"end\": 89.183, \"score\": 0.902}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 89.183, \"end\": 89.423, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"判\", \"start\": 89.423, \"end\": 89.823, \"score\": 0.945}, {\"word\": \"決\"}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 89.823, \"end\": 90.003, \"score\": 0.909}, {\"word\": \"多\", \"start\": 90.003, \"end\": 90.204, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"元\", \"start\": 90.204, \"end\": 91.464, \"score\": 0.926}, {\"word\": \"觀\"}, {\"word\": \"點\"}, {\"word\": \"與\"}, {\"word\": \"慎\"}, {\"word\": \"重\", \"start\": 91.464, \"end\": 91.684, \"score\": 0.927}, {\"word\": \"考\", \"start\": 91.684, \"end\": 92.385, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"慮\"}, {\"word\": \"尤\", \"start\": 92.385, \"end\": 92.545, \"score\": 0.907}, {\"word\": \"其\", \"start\": 92.545, \"end\": 92.685, \"score\": 0.921}, {\"word\": \"在\", \"start\": 92.685, \"end\": 93.005, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"涉\", \"start\": 93.005, \"end\": 93.205, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"及\", \"start\": 93.205, \"end\": 93.525, \"score\": 0.921}, {\"word\": \"死\", \"start\": 93.525, \"end\": 93.725, \"score\": 0.906}, {\"word\": \"刑\", \"start\": 93.725, \"end\": 93.885, \"score\": 0.892}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 93.885, \"end\": 94.065, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"重\", \"start\": 94.065, \"end\": 94.265, \"score\": 0.977}, {\"word\": \"大\", \"start\": 94.265, \"end\": 94.426, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 94.426, \"end\": 94.586, \"score\": 0.982}, {\"word\": \"件\", \"start\": 94.586, \"end\": 94.806, \"score\": 0.944}, {\"word\": \"上\", \"start\": 94.806, \"end\": 95.366, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 95.366, \"end\": 95.646, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"求\", \"start\": 95.646, \"end\": 95.966, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 95.966, \"end\": 96.166, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"官\", \"start\": 96.166, \"end\": 96.487, \"score\": 0.979}, {\"word\": \"一\", \"start\": 96.487, \"end\": 96.647, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"致\", \"start\": 96.647, \"end\": 96.827, \"score\": 0.916}, {\"word\": \"同\", \"start\": 96.827, \"end\": 97.047, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"意\", \"start\": 97.047, \"end\": 97.427, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"才\", \"start\": 97.427, \"end\": 97.607, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"可\", \"start\": 97.607, \"end\": 97.807, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"判\", \"start\": 97.807, \"end\": 98.267, \"score\": 0.951}, {\"word\": \"處\"}, {\"word\": \"死\", \"start\": 98.267, \"end\": 98.487, \"score\": 0.91}, {\"word\": \"刑\", \"start\": 98.487, \"end\": 98.708, \"score\": 0.92}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 98.708, \"end\": 98.968, \"score\": 0.908}, {\"word\": \"為\"}, {\"word\": \"了\", \"start\": 98.968, \"end\": 99.048, \"score\": 0.951}, {\"word\": \"要\", \"start\": 99.048, \"end\": 99.488, \"score\": 0.954}, {\"word\": \"確\"}, {\"word\": \"保\", \"start\": 99.488, \"end\": 99.888, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"家\", \"start\": 99.888, \"end\": 100.408, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 100.408, \"end\": 100.829, \"score\": 0.952}, {\"word\": \"輕\"}, {\"word\": \"率\", \"start\": 100.829, \"end\": 102.029, \"score\": 0.958}, {\"word\": \"剝\"}, {\"word\": \"奪\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 102.029, \"end\": 102.189, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 102.189, \"end\": 102.389, \"score\": 0.985}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 102.389, \"end\": 102.529, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 102.529, \"end\": 102.729, \"score\": 0.963}, {\"word\": \"命\", \"start\": 102.729, \"end\": 103.67, \"score\": 0.978}, {\"word\": \"將\"}, {\"word\": \"死\", \"start\": 103.67, \"end\": 103.83, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"刑\", \"start\": 103.83, \"end\": 104.05, \"score\": 0.919}, {\"word\": \"判\", \"start\": 104.05, \"end\": 105.031, \"score\": 0.938}, {\"word\": \"決\"}, {\"word\": \"門\"}, {\"word\": \"檻\"}, {\"word\": \"降\", \"start\": 105.031, \"end\": 105.271, \"score\": 0.938}, {\"word\": \"低\", \"start\": 105.271, \"end\": 105.411, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"至\", \"start\": 105.411, \"end\": 105.651, \"score\": 0.919}, {\"word\": \"多\", \"start\": 105.651, \"end\": 106.671, \"score\": 0.961}, {\"word\": \"數\"}, {\"word\": \"決\"}, {\"word\": \"反\", \"start\": 106.671, \"end\": 106.811, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"而\", \"start\": 106.811, \"end\": 107.071, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"可\", \"start\": 107.071, \"end\": 107.312, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"能\", \"start\": 107.312, \"end\": 107.852, \"score\": 0.89}, {\"word\": \"會\"}, {\"word\": \"導\"}, {\"word\": \"致\", \"start\": 107.852, \"end\": 108.052, \"score\": 0.991}, {\"word\": \"冤\", \"start\": 108.052, \"end\": 108.532, \"score\": 0.942}, {\"word\": \"錯\"}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 108.532, \"end\": 108.772, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"件\", \"start\": 108.772, \"end\": 109.473, \"score\": 0.951}, {\"word\": \"機\"}, {\"word\": \"率\", \"start\": 109.473, \"end\": 109.613, \"score\": 0.858}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 109.613, \"end\": 109.773, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"上\", \"start\": 109.773, \"end\": 110.053, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"升\", \"start\": 110.053, \"end\": 110.073, \"score\": 0.432}, {\"word\": \"違\"}, {\"word\": \"背\", \"start\": 111.014, \"end\": 111.334, \"score\": 0.937}, {\"word\": \"程\", \"start\": 111.334, \"end\": 111.554, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"序\", \"start\": 111.554, \"end\": 111.794, \"score\": 0.984}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 111.794, \"end\": 113.015, \"score\": 0.954}, {\"word\": \"義\"}, {\"word\": \"進\"}, {\"word\": \"而\", \"start\": 113.015, \"end\": 113.715, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"損\"}, {\"word\": \"害\", \"start\": 113.715, \"end\": 114.075, \"score\": 0.989}, {\"word\": \"司\", \"start\": 114.075, \"end\": 114.315, \"score\": 0.952}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 114.315, \"end\": 114.455, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 114.455, \"end\": 114.596, \"score\": 0.857}, {\"word\": \"信\", \"start\": 114.596, \"end\": 115.556, \"score\": 0.973}, {\"word\": \"賴\"}, {\"word\": \"最\", \"start\": 115.556, \"end\": 115.736, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"後\", \"start\": 115.736, \"end\": 116.436, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"死\", \"start\": 116.436, \"end\": 116.596, \"score\": 0.883}, {\"word\": \"刑\", \"start\": 116.596, \"end\": 117.937, \"score\": 0.925}, {\"word\": \"議\"}, {\"word\": \"題\"}, {\"word\": \"關\"}, {\"word\": \"係\"}, {\"word\": \"到\", \"start\": 117.937, \"end\": 118.217, \"score\": 0.928}, {\"word\": \"最\", \"start\": 118.217, \"end\": 118.397, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"基\", \"start\": 118.397, \"end\": 118.617, \"score\": 0.99}, {\"word\": \"本\", \"start\": 118.617, \"end\": 118.757, \"score\": 0.989}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 118.757, \"end\": 118.917, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 118.917, \"end\": 119.317, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 119.317, \"end\": 119.437, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"保\", \"start\": 119.437, \"end\": 119.638, \"score\": 0.941}, {\"word\": \"障\", \"start\": 119.638, \"end\": 120.158, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 120.158, \"end\": 120.638, \"score\": 0.916}, {\"word\": \"應\"}, {\"word\": \"該\"}, {\"word\": \"被\", \"start\": 120.638, \"end\": 121.118, \"score\": 0.958}, {\"word\": \"簡\"}, {\"word\": \"化\", \"start\": 121.118, \"end\": 121.578, \"score\": 0.942}, {\"word\": \"為\"}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 121.578, \"end\": 121.838, \"score\": 0.946}, {\"word\": \"治\", \"start\": 121.838, \"end\": 122.499, \"score\": 0.924}, {\"word\": \"動\"}, {\"word\": \"員\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 122.499, \"end\": 122.639, \"score\": 0.992}, {\"word\": \"手\", \"start\": 122.639, \"end\": 122.859, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"段\", \"start\": 122.859, \"end\": 123.959, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"死\", \"start\": 123.959, \"end\": 124.139, \"score\": 0.895}, {\"word\": \"刑\", \"start\": 124.139, \"end\": 124.66, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"是\", \"start\": 124.66, \"end\": 124.78, \"score\": 0.836}, {\"word\": \"一\", \"start\": 124.78, \"end\": 125.26, \"score\": 0.917}, {\"word\": \"種\"}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"家\", \"start\": 125.26, \"end\": 125.68, \"score\": 0.952}, {\"word\": \"權\"}, {\"word\": \"利\", \"start\": 125.68, \"end\": 126.08, \"score\": 0.855}, {\"word\": \"對\"}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 126.08, \"end\": 126.28, \"score\": 0.963}, {\"word\": \"命\", \"start\": 126.28, \"end\": 126.48, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 126.48, \"end\": 126.74, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"最\", \"start\": 126.74, \"end\": 128.341, \"score\": 0.937}, {\"word\": \"終\"}, {\"word\": \"剝\"}, {\"word\": \"奪\"}, {\"word\": \"應\"}, {\"word\": \"該\"}, {\"word\": \"有\", \"start\": 128.341, \"end\": 128.541, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"最\", \"start\": 128.541, \"end\": 128.961, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"嚴\"}, {\"word\": \"格\", \"start\": 128.961, \"end\": 129.101, \"score\": 0.974}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 129.101, \"end\": 129.221, \"score\": 0.994}, {\"word\": \"程\", \"start\": 129.221, \"end\": 129.442, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"序\", \"start\": 129.442, \"end\": 129.642, \"score\": 0.983}, {\"word\": \"保\", \"start\": 129.642, \"end\": 129.862, \"score\": 0.953}, {\"word\": \"障\", \"start\": 129.862, \"end\": 130.682, \"score\": 0.974}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"民\", \"start\": 130.682, \"end\": 131.342, \"score\": 0.964}, {\"word\": \"黨\"}, {\"word\": \"此\", \"start\": 131.342, \"end\": 131.562, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"次\", \"start\": 131.562, \"end\": 132.243, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"公\", \"start\": 132.243, \"end\": 132.423, \"score\": 0.903}, {\"word\": \"投\", \"start\": 132.423, \"end\": 132.583, \"score\": 0.882}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 132.583, \"end\": 135.944, \"score\": 0.962}, {\"word\": \"試\"}, {\"word\": \"圖\"}, {\"word\": \"鬆\"}, {\"word\": \"綁\"}, {\"word\": \"司\", \"start\": 135.944, \"end\": 136.104, \"score\": 0.948}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 136.104, \"end\": 136.384, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"合\", \"start\": 136.384, \"end\": 136.564, \"score\": 0.995}, {\"word\": \"一\", \"start\": 136.564, \"end\": 136.664, \"score\": 0.799}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 136.664, \"end\": 136.824, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 136.824, \"end\": 137.005, \"score\": 0.993}, {\"word\": \"度\", \"start\": 137.005, \"end\": 137.925, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"降\", \"start\": 137.925, \"end\": 138.245, \"score\": 0.981}, {\"word\": \"低\", \"start\": 138.245, \"end\": 138.865, \"score\": 0.967}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"家\", \"start\": 138.865, \"end\": 139.345, \"score\": 0.958}, {\"word\": \"殺\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 139.345, \"end\": 139.466, \"score\": 0.995}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 139.466, \"end\": 139.486, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"門\"}, {\"word\": \"檻\"}, {\"word\": \"違\"}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"違\"}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 141.707, \"end\": 142.448, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"違\"}, {\"word\": \"反\", \"start\": 142.448, \"end\": 142.688, \"score\": 0.99}, {\"word\": \"情\", \"start\": 142.688, \"end\": 142.948, \"score\": 0.987}, {\"word\": \"理\", \"start\": 142.948, \"end\": 143.529, \"score\": 0.956}, {\"word\": \"實\"}, {\"word\": \"不\", \"start\": 143.529, \"end\": 143.609, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"可\", \"start\": 143.609, \"end\": 143.869, \"score\": 0.999}, {\"word\": \"取\", \"start\": 143.869, \"end\": 144.35, \"score\": 0.965}, {\"word\": \"我\", \"start\": 144.35, \"end\": 144.63, \"score\": 0.928}, {\"word\": \"們\"}, {\"word\": \"呼\", \"start\": 144.63, \"end\": 145.31, \"score\": 0.968}, {\"word\": \"籲\"}, {\"word\": \"全\", \"start\": 145.31, \"end\": 145.891, \"score\": 0.931}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"國\"}, {\"word\": \"人\", \"start\": 145.891, \"end\": 146.411, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"基\", \"start\": 146.411, \"end\": 146.552, \"score\": 0.98}, {\"word\": \"於\", \"start\": 146.552, \"end\": 146.992, \"score\": 0.91}, {\"word\": \"對\"}, {\"word\": \"生\", \"start\": 146.992, \"end\": 147.192, \"score\": 0.963}, {\"word\": \"命\", \"start\": 147.192, \"end\": 147.733, \"score\": 0.996}, {\"word\": \"尊\", \"start\": 147.733, \"end\": 148.073, \"score\": 0.932}, {\"word\": \"嚴\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 148.073, \"end\": 148.213, \"score\": 0.875}, {\"word\": \"尊\", \"start\": 148.213, \"end\": 148.453, \"score\": 0.983}, {\"word\": \"重\", \"start\": 148.453, \"end\": 149.394, \"score\": 0.939}, {\"word\": \"對\"}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"政\", \"start\": 149.394, \"end\": 149.835, \"score\": 0.934}, {\"word\": \"體\"}, {\"word\": \"制\", \"start\": 149.835, \"end\": 149.955, \"score\": 0.85}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 149.955, \"end\": 150.055, \"score\": 0.998}, {\"word\": \"捍\", \"start\": 150.055, \"end\": 150.856, \"score\": 0.95}, {\"word\": \"衛\"}, {\"word\": \"拒\", \"start\": 150.856, \"end\": 151.396, \"score\": 0.962}, {\"word\": \"絕\"}, {\"word\": \"此\", \"start\": 151.396, \"end\": 151.496, \"score\": 0.825}, {\"word\": \"一\", \"start\": 151.496, \"end\": 152.938, \"score\": 0.971}, {\"word\": \"違\"}, {\"word\": \"憲\"}, {\"word\": \"背\", \"start\": 152.938, \"end\": 153.398, \"score\": 0.916}, {\"word\": \"離\"}, {\"word\": \"司\", \"start\": 153.398, \"end\": 153.558, \"score\": 0.891}, {\"word\": \"法\", \"start\": 153.558, \"end\": 153.798, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"正\", \"start\": 153.798, \"end\": 154.119, \"score\": 0.927}, {\"word\": \"義\"}, {\"word\": \"的\", \"start\": 154.119, \"end\": 154.439, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"公\", \"start\": 154.439, \"end\": 154.679, \"score\": 0.923}, {\"word\": \"投\", \"start\": 154.679, \"end\": 154.939, \"score\": 0.935}, {\"word\": \"提\", \"start\": 154.939, \"end\": 155.08, \"score\": 0.99}, {\"word\": \"案\", \"start\": 155.08, \"end\": 155.92, \"score\": 0.995}, {\"word\": \"大\", \"start\": 155.92, \"end\": 156.261, \"score\": 0.941}, {\"word\": \"罷\"}, {\"word\": \"免\", \"start\": 156.261, \"end\": 156.801, \"score\": 0.988}, {\"word\": \"大\", \"start\": 156.801, \"end\": 156.941, \"score\": 1.0}, {\"word\": \"成\", \"start\": 156.941, \"end\": 157.142, \"score\": 0.972}, {\"word\": \"功\", \"start\": 157.142, \"end\": 157.162, \"score\": 0.829}], \"language\": \"zh\"}","srt":"1\n00:00:10,281 --> 00:00:14,284\n主席各位議員同仁各位國人同胞大家好\n\n2\n00:00:15,506 --> 00:00:36,757\n針對國民黨所提的今天的公投案我認為在法治上有以下的幾個問題首先依據我國憲法法庭113年憲判制第八號的判決主文第六點就已經寫得非常的清楚科處死刑的判決應經各級法院和議庭法官的一致決\n\n3\n00:00:37,757 --> 00:01:03,651\n這是非常清楚的事情而且我國是法治國家憲法判決具有具屬全國各機關及人民的效力我想在憲政權利分立及法治國的原則下我們作為立法委員更應該要遵守尊重憲法法庭的判決再來公投的議題屬於法律原則的創制公投必須在\n\n4\n00:01:05,058 --> 00:01:23,940\n憲法及法律秩序內部進行而且將來相關的政府部門依據公投結果制定的法律不得抵觸大法官憲制及憲法的基本原則所以此案若違背憲法層級的解釋即時通過了相關法律修正亦屬無效\n\n5\n00:01:24,781 --> 00:01:50,073\n而且合議制度的原則設計本來就是要保障司法判決是多元觀點與慎重考慮尤其在涉及死刑的重大案件上要求法官一致同意才可判處死刑是為了要確保國家不輕率剝奪人民的生命將死刑判決門檻降低至多數決反而可能會導致冤錯案件機率的上升\n\n6\n00:01:51,014 --> 00:02:19,486\n違背程序正義進而損害司法的信賴最後死刑議題關係到最基本的人權的保障不應該被簡化為政治動員的手段死刑是一種國家權利對生命的最終剝奪應該有最嚴格的程序保障國民黨此次公投案試圖鬆綁司法合一的制度降低國家殺人的門檻\n\n7\n00:02:21,707 --> 00:02:37,162\n違憲違法違反情理實不可取我們呼籲全國國人基於對生命尊嚴的尊重對憲政體制的捍衛拒絕此一違憲背離司法正義的公投提案大罷免大成功\n\n","tsv":"start\tend\ttext\n10281\t14284\t主席各位議員同仁各位國人同胞大家好\n15506\t36757\t針對國民黨所提的今天的公投案我認為在法治上有以下的幾個問題首先依據我國憲法法庭113年憲判制第八號的判決主文第六點就已經寫得非常的清楚科處死刑的判決應經各級法院和議庭法官的一致決\n37757\t63651\t這是非常清楚的事情而且我國是法治國家憲法判決具有具屬全國各機關及人民的效力我想在憲政權利分立及法治國的原則下我們作為立法委員更應該要遵守尊重憲法法庭的判決再來公投的議題屬於法律原則的創制公投必須在\n65058\t83940\t憲法及法律秩序內部進行而且將來相關的政府部門依據公投結果制定的法律不得抵觸大法官憲制及憲法的基本原則所以此案若違背憲法層級的解釋即時通過了相關法律修正亦屬無效\n84781\t110073\t而且合議制度的原則設計本來就是要保障司法判決是多元觀點與慎重考慮尤其在涉及死刑的重大案件上要求法官一致同意才可判處死刑是為了要確保國家不輕率剝奪人民的生命將死刑判決門檻降低至多數決反而可能會導致冤錯案件機率的上升\n111014\t139486\t違背程序正義進而損害司法的信賴最後 死刑議題關係到最基本的人權的保障不應該被簡化為政治動員的手段死刑是一種國家權利對生命的最終剝奪應該有最嚴格的程序保障國民黨此次公投案試圖鬆綁司法合一的制度降低國家殺人的門檻\n141707\t157162\t違憲違法違反情理實不可取我們呼籲全國國人基於對生命尊嚴的尊重對憲政體制的捍衛拒絕此一違憲背離司法正義的公投提案大罷免大成功\n","txt":"主席各位議員同仁各位國人同胞大家好\n針對國民黨所提的今天的公投案我認為在法治上有以下的幾個問題首先依據我國憲法法庭113年憲判制第八號的判決主文第六點就已經寫得非常的清楚科處死刑的判決應經各級法院和議庭法官的一致決\n這是非常清楚的事情而且我國是法治國家憲法判決具有具屬全國各機關及人民的效力我想在憲政權利分立及法治國的原則下我們作為立法委員更應該要遵守尊重憲法法庭的判決再來公投的議題屬於法律原則的創制公投必須在\n憲法及法律秩序內部進行而且將來相關的政府部門依據公投結果制定的法律不得抵觸大法官憲制及憲法的基本原則所以此案若違背憲法層級的解釋即時通過了相關法律修正亦屬無效\n而且合議制度的原則設計本來就是要保障司法判決是多元觀點與慎重考慮尤其在涉及死刑的重大案件上要求法官一致同意才可判處死刑是為了要確保國家不輕率剝奪人民的生命將死刑判決門檻降低至多數決反而可能會導致冤錯案件機率的上升\n違背程序正義進而損害司法的信賴最後 死刑議題關係到最基本的人權的保障不應該被簡化為政治動員的手段死刑是一種國家權利對生命的最終剝奪應該有最嚴格的程序保障國民黨此次公投案試圖鬆綁司法合一的制度降低國家殺人的門檻\n違憲違法違反情理實不可取我們呼籲全國國人基於對生命尊嚴的尊重對憲政體制的捍衛拒絕此一違憲背離司法正義的公投提案大罷免大成功\n","vtt":"WEBVTT\n\n00:10.281 --> 00:14.284\n主席各位議員同仁各位國人同胞大家好\n\n00:15.506 --> 00:36.757\n針對國民黨所提的今天的公投案我認為在法治上有以下的幾個問題首先依據我國憲法法庭113年憲判制第八號的判決主文第六點就已經寫得非常的清楚科處死刑的判決應經各級法院和議庭法官的一致決\n\n00:37.757 --> 01:03.651\n這是非常清楚的事情而且我國是法治國家憲法判決具有具屬全國各機關及人民的效力我想在憲政權利分立及法治國的原則下我們作為立法委員更應該要遵守尊重憲法法庭的判決再來公投的議題屬於法律原則的創制公投必須在\n\n01:05.058 --> 01:23.940\n憲法及法律秩序內部進行而且將來相關的政府部門依據公投結果制定的法律不得抵觸大法官憲制及憲法的基本原則所以此案若違背憲法層級的解釋即時通過了相關法律修正亦屬無效\n\n01:24.781 --> 01:50.073\n而且合議制度的原則設計本來就是要保障司法判決是多元觀點與慎重考慮尤其在涉及死刑的重大案件上要求法官一致同意才可判處死刑是為了要確保國家不輕率剝奪人民的生命將死刑判決門檻降低至多數決反而可能會導致冤錯案件機率的上升\n\n01:51.014 --> 02:19.486\n違背程序正義進而損害司法的信賴最後死刑議題關係到最基本的人權的保障不應該被簡化為政治動員的手段死刑是一種國家權利對生命的最終剝奪應該有最嚴格的程序保障國民黨此次公投案試圖鬆綁司法合一的制度降低國家殺人的門檻\n\n02:21.707 --> 02:37.162\n違憲違法違反情理實不可取我們呼籲全國國人基於對生命尊嚴的尊重對憲政體制的捍衛拒絕此一違憲背離司法正義的公投提案大罷免大成功\n\n","segments":[{"start":10.281,"end":14.284,"text":"主席各位議員同仁各位國人同胞大家好"},{"start":15.506,"end":36.757,"text":"針對國民黨所提的今天的公投案我認為在法治上有以下的幾個問題首先依據我國憲法法庭113年憲判制第八號的判決主文第六點就已經寫得非常的清楚科處死刑的判決應經各級法院和議庭法官的一致決"},{"start":37.757,"end":63.651,"text":"這是非常清楚的事情而且我國是法治國家憲法判決具有具屬全國各機關及人民的效力我想在憲政權利分立及法治國的原則下我們作為立法委員更應該要遵守尊重憲法法庭的判決再來公投的議題屬於法律原則的創制公投必須在"},{"start":65.058,"end":83.94,"text":"憲法及法律秩序內部進行而且將來相關的政府部門依據公投結果制定的法律不得抵觸大法官憲制及憲法的基本原則所以此案若違背憲法層級的解釋即時通過了相關法律修正亦屬無效"},{"start":84.781,"end":110.073,"text":"而且合議制度的原則設計本來就是要保障司法判決是多元觀點與慎重考慮尤其在涉及死刑的重大案件上要求法官一致同意才可判處死刑是為了要確保國家不輕率剝奪人民的生命將死刑判決門檻降低至多數決反而可能會導致冤錯案件機率的上升"},{"start":111.014,"end":139.486,"text":"違背程序正義進而損害司法的信賴最後 死刑議題關係到最基本的人權的保障不應該被簡化為政治動員的手段死刑是一種國家權利對生命的最終剝奪應該有最嚴格的程序保障國民黨此次公投案試圖鬆綁司法合一的制度降低國家殺人的門檻"},{"start":141.707,"end":157.162,"text":"違憲違法違反情理實不可取我們呼籲全國國人基於對生命尊嚴的尊重對憲政體制的捍衛拒絕此一違憲背離司法正義的公投提案大罷免大成功"}]}}},"gazette":{"lineno":133,"blocks":[["王委員正旭：（16時8分）主席、各位立院同仁、各位國人同胞，大家好。針對國民黨今天所提的公投案，我認為在法制上有以下幾個問題：首先，依據我國憲法法庭113年憲判字第8號的判決，主文第六點就已經寫得非常清楚，科處死刑的判決，應經各級法院合議庭法官一致決，這是非常清楚的事情，而且我國是法治國家，憲法判決具有拘束全國各機關及人民的效力，我想在憲政權力分立及法治國的原則下，我們作為立法委員，更應該要遵守、尊重憲法法庭的判決。","再來，公投的議題屬於法律原則的創制，公投必須在憲法及法律秩序內部進行，而且將來相關的政府部門依據公投結果制定的法律，不得牴觸大法官的限制及憲法的基本原則，所以此案若違背憲法層級的解釋，即使通過了，相關法律修正亦屬無效。而且合議制度的設計，本來就是要保障司法判決之多元觀點與慎重考慮，尤其在涉及死刑的重大案件上，要求法官要一致同意才可判處死刑，是為了要確保國家不輕率剝奪人民的生命，將死刑判決門檻降低至多數決，反而可能會導致冤錯案件機率上升，違背程序正義，進而損害人民對司法的信賴。","最後，死刑議題關係到最基本人權的保障，不應該被簡化為政治動員的手段。死刑是一種國家權力對生命的最終剝奪，應該有最嚴格的程序保障，國民黨此次公投案試圖鬆綁司法合議的制度、降低國家殺人的門檻，違憲、違法、違反情理實不可取。我們呼籲全國國人，基於對生命尊嚴的尊重，對憲政體制的捍衛，拒絕此一違憲、背離司法正義的公投提案。大罷免，大成功！"],["主席：謝謝王委員。","下一位我們請陳秀寳委員發言。"]],"agenda":{"page_end":100,"meet_id":"院會-11-3-12","speakers":["韓國瑜","江啟臣","莊瑞雄","鍾佳濱","沈伯洋","王義川","黃捷","李柏毅","陳培瑜","蘇巧慧","沈發惠","吳思瑤","林楚茵","陳亭妃","賴瑞隆","張雅琳","李坤城","徐富癸","張宏陸","郭昱晴","郭國文","林月琴","陳俊宇","王美惠","林俊憲","劉建國","李昆澤","許智傑","林宜瑾","邱議瑩","王定宇","何欣純","陳瑩","黃秀芳","伍麗華Saidhai‧Tahovecahe","吳琪銘","羅美玲","陳素月","王正旭","陳秀寳","范雲","吳秉叡","賴惠員","邱志偉","陳昭姿","張啓楷","吳宗憲","羅智強","牛煦庭","賴士葆","徐巧芯","洪孟楷","林淑芬","林岱樺","陳冠廷"],"page_start":64,"meetingDate":["2025-05-16"],"gazette_id":"1144801","agenda_lcidc_ids":["1144801_00002","1144801_00003"],"meet_name":"立法院第11屆第3會期第12次會議紀錄","content":"本院委員吳宗憲等52人擬具公投提案主文為：「您是否同意『各級法院合議庭法官判處死刑不須\n一致決』之政策？」請公決案─通過─","agenda_id":"1144801_00004"}}}